Best Tires for Tesla Model Y – 10 Options Reviewed

Finding the right tires for your Tesla Model Y can feel overwhelming. This guide cuts through the jargon, comparing ten different tire options – from performance summer tires to essential spare tire kits – to help you make the best choice for your driving style and budget. We’ll cover everything from performance and handling to noise levels and longevity, giving you the insights you need for a confident purchase.

IMAGE	PRODUCT NAME	AMAZON LINK
	Lexani LX-Twenty 255/40ZR20 101W XL	View on Amazon
	Modern Spare – Fits 2020-2026 Tesla Model Y – Compact…	View on Amazon
	StanceMagic Complete Spare Wheel and Tire – Compatible with…	View on Amazon
	TACTILIAN Car Tire Valve Stem Caps for Tesla Model 3,…	View on Amazon
	TACTILIAN Red Tire Valve Stem Caps for Tesla Model 3,…	View on Amazon
	VEVOR Tesla Model 3 Wheel Covers Hubcaps 18 Inch,…	View on Amazon
	Goodyear 255/40R20 101W XL GOODYEAR EAG F1 ASYM 5 SBL…	View on Amazon
	Tesla Model Y Wheel Covers 19 Inch 2020-2024 Full Fit…	View on Amazon
	Pirelli Scorpion Zero Street Radial Rear Tire 285/35R22XL…	View on Amazon
	Car Tire Valve Stem Caps Compatible with Model 3, S,…	View on Amazon

1. Lexani LX-Twenty 255/40ZR20 101W XL

The Lexani LX-Twenty is a performance summer tire designed for warmer climates. Its asymmetrical tread pattern provides sporty handling, while grooves and sipes enhance wet traction. It’s known for a relatively quiet ride, but its performance comes at the cost of reduced lifespan.

• Key Features: 55,000-mile tread life warranty, asymmetrical tread, good wet traction, relatively quiet ride.
• Pros: Sporty handling, good wet grip, comfortable ride.
• Cons: Shorter lifespan than some alternatives, not suitable for winter conditions.
• User Feedback Summary: Generally positive reviews for handling and comfort, but some users report shorter than expected tread life.

1. Modern Spare – Fits 2020-2026 Tesla Model Y – Compact…

This isn’t a full-size tire replacement, but a compact spare designed specifically for the Model Y. It’s a lifesaver in a pinch, allowing you to limp to a service center instead of being stranded. The kit also includes helpful tools.

• Key Features: Model-specific design, lightweight alloy wheel, included jack and tools, optional Ultra-Kit with added safety features.
• Pros: Peace of mind, essential for emergencies, well-designed kit.
• Cons: Not a full-size tire replacement, limited speed and distance capabilities.
• User Feedback Summary: Highly rated for its convenience and completeness. Many appreciate the included tools.

1. StanceMagic Complete Spare Wheel and Tire – Compatible with…

Another compact spare option, the StanceMagic kit includes everything you need for a temporary fix. It’s designed to minimize interference with your Model Y’s systems.

• Key Features: Compact spare tire and wheel, scissor jack, socket wrench, storage bag.
• Pros: Complete kit, easy to use, correct size for many Model Y trims.
• Cons: Not a full-size replacement, limited speed and distance capabilities, compatibility limitations.
• User Feedback Summary: Users praise the kit’s completeness and ease of use.

1. TACTILIAN Car Tire Valve Stem Caps for Tesla Model 3,…

These are simple valve stem caps with a subtle Tesla logo. While not tires themselves, they’re a small upgrade that adds a touch of personalization.

• Key Features: Aluminum construction, matte black finish, subtle Tesla logo, supports US veterans.
• Pros: Stylish, durable, supports a good cause.
• Cons: Minor upgrade, not functional beyond aesthetics.
• User Feedback Summary: Positive feedback for the look and quality.

1. TACTILIAN Red Tire Valve Stem Caps for Tesla Model 3,…

Similar to the black caps, but in red. A simple way to add a pop of color.

• Key Features: Aluminum construction, red finish, subtle Tesla logo, supports US veterans.
• Pros: Stylish, durable, supports a good cause.
• Cons: Minor upgrade, not functional beyond aesthetics.
• User Feedback Summary: Positive feedback for the look and quality.

1. VEVOR Tesla Model 3 Wheel Covers Hubcaps 18 Inch,…

These hubcaps are designed to fit 18-inch wheels on Model 3s (check compatibility with your Model Y). They offer a visual refresh without replacing the tires themselves.

• Key Features: 1:1 mold design, easy installation, durable material.
• Pros: Improved aesthetics, easy installation, protects the hub.
• Cons: Only for specific wheel sizes, might not suit all aesthetic preferences.
• User Feedback Summary: Generally positive feedback, but some users report fitment issues.

1. Goodyear 255/40R20 101W XL GOODYEAR EAG F1 ASYM 5 SBL…

The Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 is a high-performance summer tire known for its excellent handling and braking performance in dry conditions.

• Key Features: Premium ultra-high-performance summer tire, superior braking.
• Pros: Excellent handling and braking, sporty feel.
• Cons: Not suitable for winter conditions, shorter lifespan than all-season tires, expensive.
• User Feedback Summary: Highly rated by performance-oriented drivers.

1. Tesla Model Y Wheel Covers 19 Inch 2020-2024 Full Fit…

These wheel covers fit 19-inch wheels on specific Model Y years. They offer protection and a new look. Note the included tire repair kit is a bonus.

• Key Features: Durable ABS+PC material, easy installation, included tire repair kit.
• Pros: Protects wheels, improves aesthetics, handy repair kit included.
• Cons: Specific fitment, may not suit all tastes.
• User Feedback Summary: Users like the look and protection offered.

1. Pirelli Scorpion Zero Street Radial Rear Tire 285/35R22XL…

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero Street is an all-season tire designed for SUVs and crossovers. Its all-season capabilities offer flexibility for various weather conditions.

• Key Features: All-season capability, high speed rating.
• Pros: Versatility for different weather, good overall performance.
• Cons: May not match the performance of dedicated summer tires.
• User Feedback Summary: Decent reviews for all-around performance.

1. Car Tire Valve Stem Caps Compatible with Model 3, S,…

Another set of valve stem caps, these are simple and functional, protecting your valve stems.

• Key Features: Aluminum alloy construction, corrosion-resistant, easy to install.
• Pros: Protects valve stems, durable, simple design.
• Cons: Not visually striking, minor upgrade.
• User Feedback Summary: Generally positive feedback for their functionality and durability.

Practical Buying Advice:

Consider your climate and driving style. If you live in an area with harsh winters, all-season or winter tires are essential. If performance is your priority and you live in a warmer climate, summer tires offer superior handling. A compact spare is a wise investment regardless of your tire choice.

Final Verdict:

The “best” tire depends on your individual needs. For performance, the Lexani LX-Twenty or Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 are strong contenders. For year-round use, the Pirelli Scorpion Zero Street is a versatile option. Don’t forget the importance of a compact spare like the Modern Spare or StanceMagic options for peace of mind. The valve stem caps are purely aesthetic upgrades.

FAQ:

Q: How often should I rotate my Tesla Model Y tires?
A: Consult your owner’s manual for the recommended rotation schedule, typically every 5,000-7,500 miles.

Q: What tire pressure should I use for my Tesla Model Y?
A: The recommended tire pressure is usually found on a sticker inside the driver’s side doorjamb or in your owner’s manual. Always check and adjust pressure when tires are cold.

Q: What size tires fit my Tesla Model Y?
A: The correct tire size depends on the year and trim level of your Model Y. Check your owner’s manual or the sidewall of your current tires.

Q: Can I use different brands of tires on my Tesla Model Y?
A: It’s generally recommended to use the same brand and model of tire on all four wheels for optimal performance and handling.

Q: How do I know when I need to replace my tires?
A: Check your tire tread depth regularly using a tread depth gauge. When the tread depth reaches 2/32 of an inch or the wear bars are visible, it’s time for new tires.

Q: Are run-flat tires a good option for my Tesla Model Y?
A: Tesla Model Ys do not typically come with run-flat tires. While they offer the ability to drive a short distance on a flat, they often ride harsher and are more expensive to replace. A compact spare is a more practical solution.