I recently spent time troubleshooting a persistent oil consumption issue that turned out to be a clogged Positive Crankcase Ventilation (PCV) valve. Choosing the right replacement isn’t just about saving money; it’s critical for maintaining engine longevity and efficiency. When searching for the best aftermarket pcv valve, quality, durability, and fitment are everything. This comprehensive guide dives deep into five top-rated options, helping you find the reliable component your vehicle needs for optimal long-term performance.
Contents
- ACDelco Gold 19313317 Positive Crankcase Ventilation (PCV) Valve
- Genuine Hyundai 26740-2G000 PCV Valve
- ACDelco Gold 19313320 Positive Crankcase Ventilation (PCV) Valve
- FANHAY PCV Valve Diaphragm Cover with Membrane, Replace 917-147, 31319643 Fit for Volvo 2010-2016 XC60, 2008-2015 XC70, 2007-2014 XC90, 2011-2016 S60, 2007-2015 S80, 2008-2010 V70, 2015-2016 V60
- Amavoler 17130-PK1-003 17130-PM6-003 PCV Valve Grommet Kit 90° Aftermarket Replacement Parts Fit For Honda Accord Odyssey Civic Prelude Acura Lexus Isuzu Toyota.(1 Set).
- Comparison and Buying Insights
- Final Verdict
- Frequently Asked Questions About the best aftermarket pcv valve
ACDelco Gold 19313317 Positive Crankcase Ventilation (PCV) Valve
The ACDelco Gold line represents a professional-grade selection, offering a significant step up from standard economy parts. This particular PCV valve is engineered to provide the reliable performance and dependability that mechanics trust. It’s a premium aftermarket replacement that focuses heavily on matching the original equipment’s exact fit, form, and function, ensuring a straightforward installation and long service life. If you want OEM quality without the OEM price tag, this is often a fantastic choice.
Key features that stand out:
– Professional Grade: Offers high dependability for reliable engine performance.
– Exact Specifications: Manufactured to meet expectations for fit, form, and function.
– Durability: Designed using robust materials suitable for long-term crankcase ventilation management.
Pros:
– Excellent balance of price and quality (near OEM performance).
– Wide vehicle compatibility across many GM models.
– Provides consistent vacuum regulation.
Cons:
– Installation can be cramped depending on the vehicle application.
Best for:
Drivers seeking a high-quality, dependable aftermarket PCV valve that rivals original equipment performance.
Expert Opinion: This component is ideal for mechanics who require reliable, repeatable results across different client vehicles. The Gold line consistently delivers the precise calibration necessary for modern engine management systems.
Genuine Hyundai 26740-2G000 PCV Valve
While we are discussing the best aftermarket pcv valve options, sometimes the original equipment manufacturer (OEM) part simply cannot be beaten—especially for sensitive Korean engines. The Genuine Hyundai PCV Valve is precisely that. This is not an aftermarket component; it is the exact OEM factory part, guaranteeing 100% compatibility and meeting the manufacturer’s stringent quality control standards. If your vehicle is still under warranty or you simply want assurance that the valve is tuned specifically for your engine’s precise pressure requirements, the OEM route is highly recommended.
Key features that stand out:
– Genuine OEM Factory Part: Exact fitment guaranteed by the manufacturer.
– Specific Calibration: Designed and tested specifically for Hyundai/Kia pressure requirements.
– Superior Quality: Built with materials chosen for maximum durability by the vehicle maker.
Pros:
– Guaranteed perfect fit and function for specific Hyundai models.
– Peace of mind knowing it meets factory quality standards.
– Optimized performance for fuel efficiency and emission control.
Cons:
– Typically more expensive than most true aftermarket alternatives.
Best for:
Owners of Hyundai/Kia vehicles who prioritize exact OEM fitment and factory specifications above all else.
Expert Opinion: When dealing with specific engine requirements, particularly those prone to oil burning issues related to ventilation, starting with the genuine part eliminates a lot of guesswork associated with generic fitments.
ACDelco Gold 19313320 Positive Crankcase Ventilation (PCV) Valve
Another strong contender from the ACDelco Gold series, the 19313320 upholds the line’s reputation for high-quality, professional-grade components. Like its counterpart, this valve is a premium aftermarket replacement designed to provide the performance and durability you expect from a reliable brand. It is manufactured to ensure precise fitment and dependable operation, making it an excellent choice if you’re looking to restore your crankcase pressure regulation system back to its optimal state without paying dealer pricing.
Key features that stand out:
– Consistent Quality: Maintains the dependability standards of the ACDelco Gold line.
– Premium Aftermarket: Provides robust construction suitable for demanding applications.
– Guaranteed Function: Ensures proper sealing and regulated air flow.
Pros:
– High reliability and predictable performance.
– Excellent value compared to dealership pricing.
– Easy to source and widely available.
Cons:
– Specific vehicle compatibility requires careful cross-referencing of the part number.
Best for:
Owners needing a consistently reliable, high-end aftermarket replacement that offers OEM-like function for specific vehicle models.
Expert Opinion: ACDelco has mastered the aftermarket replacement market. When recommending the best aftermarket pcv valve for general repair, this series is always a top pick due to the consistency of its pressure regulating spring mechanism.
FANHAY PCV Valve Diaphragm Cover with Membrane, Replace 917-147, 31319643 Fit for Volvo 2010-2016 XC60, 2008-2015 XC70, 2007-2014 XC90, 2011-2016 S60, 2007-2015 S80, 2008-2010 V70, 2015-2016 V60
This FANHAY kit offers a specialized solution, focusing on replacing only the faulty PCV valve diaphragm and cover rather than the entire valve assembly (often integrated into the engine cover on certain vehicles, particularly Volvos). This approach is highly effective for vehicles where the membrane tears, leading to major vacuum leaks, poor idle, and oil consumption. It’s a direct replacement engineered to seamlessly match the fit and function of the original diaphragm, restoring full functionality without the massive cost of replacing the entire engine cover assembly.
Key features that stand out:
– Cost-Effective Repair: Replaces only the prone-to-fail membrane, saving significant money.
– Specific Volvo Fitment: Engineered specifically for 3.0L and 3.2L Volvo L6 engines listed.
– Robust Construction: Crafted from high-quality materials designed for a long service life.
Pros:
– Avoids the expense of purchasing a whole new valve cover assembly.
– Designed for an exact fit to restore original functionality.
– High-quality membrane material resists tears and degradation.
Cons:
– Requires more intricate installation than a simple screw-in valve replacement.
Best for:
Volvo owners (3.0L/3.2L) dealing with common diaphragm failure, looking for a targeted, budget-conscious repair solution.
Expert Opinion: For vehicles like certain Volvos or BMWs where the PCV system is built into the valve cover, diaphragm repair kits like this are invaluable. They offer a specific fix that often resolves the pressure regulation issue completely, making them a very smart way to choose a component among the best aftermarket pcv valve options.
Amavoler 17130-PK1-003 17130-PM6-003 PCV Valve Grommet Kit 90° Aftermarket Replacement Parts Fit For Honda Accord Odyssey Civic Prelude Acura Lexus Isuzu Toyota.(1 Set).
The Amavoler kit provides a comprehensive solution for older Honda and Acura models, often where not only the valve itself is failing, but also the crucial sealing grommet in the valve cover. This aftermarket replacement kit includes both the 90° PCV valve and the necessary grommet, ensuring a complete and leak-free repair. Given the wide compatibility with popular Japanese vehicles spanning many years, this kit is an extremely popular and practical choice for DIY mechanics tackling crankcase ventilation issues.
Key features that stand out:
– Complete Kit: Includes both the PCV valve and the sealing grommet.
– Wide Compatibility: Matches specific OEM numbers for numerous Honda, Acura, and Lexus applications.
– Durable Construction: Made from high-quality plastic and rubber materials for longevity.
Pros:
– Eliminates common leaks caused by old, brittle grommets.
– Excellent value for money due to the included components.
– Direct replacement design ensures ease of installation.
Cons:
– The plastic quality may not match OEM durability in extreme heat over many years.
Best for:
DIYers and owners of older Japanese vehicles (especially Honda/Acura) who need a cost-effective, full replacement of both the valve and the grommet.
Expert Opinion: When replacing a PCV valve, the grommet is frequently overlooked, leading to persistent vacuum leaks. This kit proactively solves that problem, making it one of the smarter selections if you are performing general maintenance on an older vehicle and looking for a capable best aftermarket pcv valve setup.
Comparison and Buying Insights
When deciding between the top options for a best aftermarket pcv valve, it helps to categorize your needs. If you drive a standard vehicle and need reliable performance without the premium OEM cost, ACDelco Gold components offer excellent consistency and durability, making them a robust choice for general repairs. These parts are usually calibrated very closely to factory specs.
However, if you own a vehicle known for highly sensitive pressure systems (like some European or specialized Japanese engines), investing in an OEM component like the Genuine Hyundai part is often the safest bet, as calibration is non-negotiable for smooth idle and oil control.
For those tackling specific failures, repair kits are game-changers. The FANHAY diaphragm kit demonstrates that you don’t always need to replace an expensive assembly; sometimes, targeted component replacement is smarter. Similarly, the Amavoler kit highlights the importance of the often-forgotten grommet—a part crucial for sealing that must be replaced alongside the valve for a lasting repair. Always prioritize perfect fitment; a valve that seals improperly or is improperly calibrated will do more harm than good.
Final Verdict
Choosing the correct PCV valve hinges entirely on your vehicle and priorities:
For Maximum Quality and Assurance: If budget allows, choose the Genuine Hyundai 26740-2G000 PCV Valve. OEM fitment guarantees the pressure is exactly what the engine demands.
For The Best Overall Value: The ACDelco Gold 19313317 or 19313320 (depending on application) strikes the perfect balance, providing professional quality that is highly reliable and easily accessible.
For The Smartest Repair (Specific Applications): The FANHAY Diaphragm Kit is the winner for targeted, high-value repairs on complex European PCV systems.
Frequently Asked Questions About the best aftermarket pcv valve
What are the common symptoms of a failing PCV valve?
A clogged or faulty PCV valve can cause several engine problems. Common symptoms include increased oil consumption, a visible increase in smoke from the tailpipe (often blue smoke during deceleration), rough engine idle, or the engine stalling. If the valve fails open, you may experience a vacuum leak leading to a “whooshing” sound or whistling noise under the hood.
How often should I replace my PCV valve?
The replacement interval for the positive crankcase ventilation valve varies widely by vehicle and driving conditions. As a general rule, many manufacturers recommend inspecting the valve every 30,000 miles and replacing it every 40,000 to 50,000 miles, especially on older vehicles or those that run conventional oils. Newer vehicles may have longer intervals, but checking the valve annually is good practice.
Is an OEM or aftermarket PCV valve better for my engine?
This depends on your specific vehicle and budget. OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts, like the Genuine Hyundai option reviewed, offer guaranteed exact fitment and calibration. However, premium aftermarket brands like ACDelco Gold often offer near-identical performance and durability at a lower cost. If you drive a performance vehicle or one sensitive to vacuum changes, OEM is safer. For general use, a high-quality best aftermarket pcv valve is usually sufficient.
Can I clean my old PCV valve instead of buying a new one?
For older, simple ball-check style PCV valves, cleaning with carburetor cleaner may temporarily restore function. However, the internal spring mechanism can often remain coated with sludge, and the valve may quickly clog again. We generally recommend replacing the valve entirely, as they are relatively inexpensive parts, and replacement ensures optimal engine ventilation for the longest duration.
How do I check if my PCV valve is bad?
A simple check involves removing the valve from the valve cover (leaving the hose attached) while the engine is running at idle. If the valve is working correctly, you should hear a slight sucking sound as the valve draws vacuum, and it should rattle softly when you shake it (indicating the internal plunger is moving). If the valve is silent or there is no change in engine noise when removing the cap, it is likely clogged and needs replacement.
What happens if I install the wrong PCV valve?
Installing the wrong component, even an otherwise high-quality best aftermarket pcv valve, can cause severe issues. PCV valves are calibrated for specific engine vacuum pressure. An improperly calibrated valve can lead to poor fuel economy, excessive oil consumption, sludge buildup due to poor ventilation, or even internal engine pressure that blows out oil seals. Always match the part number precisely to your vehicle.
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this site.
