Best Men’s Hair Cream: 10 Best Choices

As someone who’s always experimenting with different hair products, finding the best men’s hair cream has been a bit of a journey for me. From trying to get that perfect casual look to battling frizz on a humid day, I’ve seen my fair share of gels, pomades, and waxes. But lately, hair cream has really stood out. Why? Because it offers a fantastic balance: usually a natural finish, some hold, and often a lot of conditioning benefits without feeling stiff or greasy. It’s truly a versatile styling product that many guys overlook. In this guide, I’ve put together my hands-on insights into 10 popular men’s hair creams, giving you the lowdown on their features, pros, cons, and who they’re best for. Whether you’re after a strong hold, a natural look, or something to tame your curls, you’ll find a reliable option here.

IMAGE	PRODUCT NAME	AMAZON LINK
	Brylcreem 3-in-1 Original High Shine Men’s Hair Cream for…	View on Amazon
	Cremo Hair Styling Cream, Barber Grade, Medium Hold, Medium…	View on Amazon
	Tea Tree Shaping Cream, Hair Styling Cream, Long-Lasting…	View on Amazon
	American Crew Men’s Hair Forming Cream, Like Hair Gel…	View on Amazon
	American Crew Men’s Fiber Cream, Like Hair Gel with…	View on Amazon
	Rocky Mountain Barber Company Styling Hair Cream, White	View on Amazon
	Suavecito Hair Cream Pump Bottle Medium Shine All Day…	View on Amazon
	Redken Brews Cream Pomade For Men – Provides Medium Hold…	View on Amazon
	American Crew Men’s Hair Forming Cream (OLD VERSION), Like…	View on Amazon
	Harry’s Taming Hair Cream for Men with Soft Hold and…	View on Amazon

Brylcreem 3-in-1 Original High Shine Men’s Hair Cream

If you’re after that classic, high-shine look your grandpa might have rocked, Brylcreem is an iconic choice that’s surprisingly still relevant. This cream gives a light hold, letting you achieve a slick-back style or just keep things tidy, all while adding a noticeable sheen. What I really appreciate is that it doesn’t feel sticky like some gels and it’s alcohol-free, so it won’t dry out your hair, which is a big plus. It’s also great for fine hair, as it adds a bit of body without any heavy residue. Just a dime-sized amount after shampooing, and you’re good to go for that effortlessly classic vibe.

• Light hold and high-shine hair cream for men.
• Leaves hair healthy, soft, and manageable.
• Holds like a hair wax with a classic slick-back look without stickiness or greasiness.
• Alcohol-free formula to prevent hair dryness.
• Adds body to fine hair without sticky mess or residue.

Pros:
– Achieves a classic, glossy look.
– Non-drying and doesn’t feel sticky.
– Adds volume to fine hair.
– Very affordable and widely available.

Cons:
– The high shine isn’t for everyone.
– Light hold may not suffice for very unruly hair.

Best for: Achieving a classic, high-shine slick-back or for fine hair needing a touch of volume and sheen.

User feedback summary: Many users praise its enduring quality for a classic look, appreciating that it keeps hair soft and manageable without feeling heavy or sticky.

Cremo Hair Styling Cream, Barber Grade

Cremo’s Styling Cream is a fantastic all-rounder if you’re looking for a natural, flexible style. It provides a medium hold that isn’t stiff, allowing you to easily restyle your hair throughout the day. I’ve found it super versatile – you can use it on dry hair for a textured, “slept-in” look, or even reactivate it in unwashed hair with a little water to refresh your style. It delivers a barber-quality finish with a medium shine that looks healthy, not greasy. Plus, its compact 4 oz size makes it perfect for tossing into your gym bag or travel kit.

• Medium hold flexibility for a natural look.
• Allows for effortless restyling throughout the day.
• Versatile styling for all hair types, can be applied to dry hair for texture.
• Easy to manage – reactivate style by adding product to unwashed hair.
• Provides a polished appearance with medium shine, without looking greasy.

Pros:
– Excellent for flexible, natural-looking styles.
– Easy to restyle throughout the day.
– Suitable for all hair types.
– Doesn’t leave a greasy residue.
– Convenient for travel.

Cons:
– Medium hold might not be sufficient for very demanding styles or very thick hair.
– Some might prefer a stronger or completely matte finish.

Best for: Everyday natural styling, flexible control, and easy restyling, especially for those who want a non-greasy finish.

User feedback summary: Customers frequently commend its non-greasy feel and the ability to achieve a natural, reworkable style that lasts all day.

Tea Tree Shaping Cream, Hair Styling Cream

The Tea Tree Shaping Cream is a go-to for guys who want serious texture and definition with a long-lasting, flexible hold. This isn’t just a basic cream; its “mesh-like fibers” actually help you sculpt your hair, and the strong, flexible resins ensure your style stays put without feeling like a helmet. While it mentions “natural straightening for curly hair,” I’ve found it’s more about defining and taming curls or adding control to thicker, more unruly hair, making it look much more polished. Plus, you get that signature refreshing Tea Tree scent, which is always a bonus.

• Active treatment ingredient based on keratin for hair health.
• Mesh-like fibers create pliable definition or separation.
• Strong, flexible resins provide long-lasting hold.
• Enables moveable texture without stiffness.

Pros:
– Provides strong hold with flexibility for a natural feel.
– Excellent for creating textured looks and defining curls.
– Long-lasting hold that keeps hair in shape.
– Refreshing Tea Tree scent.

Cons:
– The term “natural straightening” can be misleading; it’s more about control and definition for curls.
– Might be too firm for those seeking a very light hold.

Best for: Sculpting defined, textured styles, especially for those with thicker or curly hair needing significant control and long-lasting hold.

User feedback summary: Reviewers consistently praise its ability to provide strong, yet flexible, hold and definition, especially highlighting its effectiveness for textured styles and the refreshing scent.

American Crew Men’s Hair Forming Cream

American Crew’s Forming Cream is a true classic in the men’s grooming world, and for good reason. It’s an easy-to-use styling cream that’s often compared to hair gel but without the stiffness. I find it perfect for getting a groomed, wavy, or textured look with a pleasant medium hold and medium shine. What I really like is how it helps hair look thicker, making it a fantastic choice for guys with finer hair or those just starting to explore styling products. It’s super straightforward: apply to towel-dried hair, comb through, and let it do its thing.

• Easy-to-use styling cream that creates wave separation or curl definition.
• Ideal for a groomed, wavy, textured look.
• Provides medium hold and medium shine.
• Helps hair look thicker.
• Recommended for short to medium hair length.

Pros:
– Versatile for various natural-looking styles.
– Enhances hair’s appearance, making it look thicker.
– Good balance of hold and shine.
– Excellent for styling beginners.

Cons:
– Not for those seeking a very strong hold or a completely matte finish.
– Some might find the shine too subtle.

Best for: Achieving a natural, groomed, or textured look on short to medium hair with a reliable medium hold and shine.

User feedback summary: This product is a staple for many, often cited for its consistent quality, pleasant scent, and ability to deliver a polished yet natural look without stiffness.

American Crew Men’s Fiber Cream

Don’t let the “cream” in the name fool you entirely; American Crew’s Fiber Cream is more like a moisture-rich gel that delivers high hold and high shine. If you’re looking for a product to give you a very defined look while taming frizz, this is a strong contender. It’s packed with moisturizing and conditioning benefits, which is great for keeping your hair healthy, and it helps achieve a frizz-free, defined appearance. I’ve used it both on damp hair for maximum definition and lightly on dry hair for a quick style touch-up, and it always delivers a polished, natural shine.

• Moisture-rich gel that provides a defined look and tames hair.
• Leaves a natural shine finish.
• Ideal for textured definition, frizz-free hair, and a defined look.
• Offers high hold and high shine.
• Provides moisturizing and conditioning benefits.

Pros:
– Delivers strong hold and definition.
– Effectively tames frizz and conditions hair.
– Leaves a natural, healthy shine.
– Versatile for use on damp or dry hair.

Cons:
– The high hold and shine might be too intense for those wanting a subtle look.
– Applying too liberally on damp hair could feel heavy for some.

Best for: Guys who need a high hold for defined styles, want to control frizz, and appreciate a noticeable, natural shine.

User feedback summary: Users with thicker or unruly hair often praise its exceptional hold and ability to maintain a defined, frizz-free style with a healthy sheen.

Rocky Mountain Barber Company Styling Hair Cream

This styling cream from Rocky Mountain Barber Company stands out with its natural ingredients and user-friendly design. It comes in a unique pump-style cap, making application incredibly easy and mess-free. What I love is its light, reworkable hold that effortlessly enhances natural waves and curls while adding a bit of texture and shine. It’s surprisingly versatile for all hair lengths – whether you’re aiming for a soft, loose look on short hair or taming frizz on longer locks. With Argan, Coconut, and Jojoba oils, it actually hydrates and conditions your hair, leaving it feeling great. And the subtle Forest Mint scent (from essential oils, no artificial fragrance!) is super refreshing.

• Light, reworkable hold with easy pump application.
• Enhances waves and curls while adding texture and shine.
• Works with all hair lengths – tames frizz, keeps hair in place.
• Packed with hair nourishing ingredients like Argan Oil, Coconut Oil, and Jojoba Oil.
• Signature Forest Mint Scent from peppermint and eucalyptus essential oils.

Pros:
– Contains natural, nourishing oils for hair health.
– Light hold allows for natural movement and restyling.
– Pump dispenser makes application clean and simple.
– Subtle, natural, and refreshing scent.
– Generous 8 oz bottle lasts a long time.

Cons:
– Light hold won’t suit styles requiring strong control.
– The unique scent, while natural, might not appeal to everyone.

Best for: Those seeking a light, flexible hold with natural ingredients and hydrating benefits, suitable for all hair lengths and natural wave enhancement.

User feedback summary: Many appreciate its light, natural hold and how it leaves hair feeling healthy and soft, with the refreshing mint scent being a consistent highlight.

Suavecito Hair Cream Pump Bottle

Suavecito is well-known for its pomades, but their Hair Cream is a fantastic alternative for a different kind of style. This water-based cream offers a soft, all-day light hold that’s perfect for keeping hair soft and adding moisture and shine without any crunchiness or stiffness. It’s a dream for guys with long, curly, or wavy hair as it helps control frizz and enhances your natural wave pattern without weighing it down. Being water-based, it washes out super easily with no residue, which is a huge plus. And, of course, it comes with that classic masculine barbershop scent that Suavecito is famous for.

• Softens and conditions hair while retaining an all-day light hold.
• Adds moisture and shine without making hair crunchy or hard.
• Water-based formula for easy wash-out and no residue.
• Excellent for long, curly, or wavy hair to control frizz and retain natural wave.
• Comes with a classic barbershop scent.

Pros:
– Keeps hair soft and natural-feeling.
– Perfect for enhancing natural curls and waves.
– Washes out effortlessly.
– Iconic barbershop scent.

Cons:
– Only provides a light hold, so not suitable for structured styles.
– The shine might be too much for those preferring a matte look.

Best for: Taming and enhancing long, curly, or wavy hair for a soft, natural, and frizz-free look with an easy-to-wash-out formula.

User feedback summary: Highly praised for its ability to keep curly and wavy hair soft and defined without stickiness, along with its famous barbershop aroma.

Redken Brews Cream Pomade For Men

Redken Brews Cream Pomade is a great choice for guys who want a versatile styling product that offers both hold and flexibility. This water-based pomade (despite being called a cream pomade) gives a medium hold and control with a natural, low shine finish, which I find ideal for creating smooth, flexible styles like pompadours without looking too “done.” It’s designed to provide a long-lasting hold without any crunch or flaking, and it actually adds a bit of volume and natural dimension to your hair. You can work it through dry or damp hair, making it really adaptable to your routine.

• Water-based hair pomade providing medium hold and control.
• Long-lasting hold with no crunch or flaking.
• Ideal for creating pompadours and smooth, flexible styles.
• Leaves hair with a natural, low shine finish.
• Adds volume and natural dimension.

Pros:
– Achieves versatile, flexible styles like pompadours.
– No flaking or crunchy feel.
– Provides natural-looking hold with low shine.
– Adds volume and texture.

Cons:
– Low shine might be too matte for those wanting more gloss.
– Medium hold may not be strong enough for very structured looks.

Best for: Creating flexible, medium-hold styles such as pompadours, or for general everyday styling that requires a natural, low-shine finish.

User feedback summary: Users appreciate its balanced hold and natural finish, often noting its effectiveness for achieving a clean, flexible style without any residue or stiffness.

American Crew Men’s Hair Forming Cream (OLD VERSION)

This product is listed as the previous version of the American Crew Forming Cream, and it comes with an important disclaimer: American Crew itself cannot guarantee the quality of these older stock items. While the original formula was beloved for its pliable medium hold and medium shine (creating a natural, healthy look), and its easy application and wash-out, buying this version carries a risk. If you happen to get a fresh batch, it might deliver the classic performance; however, there’s a chance you could end up with a less-than-ideal product due to its age. Proceed with caution.

• The previous version of the American Crew Forming Cream.
• Provides a pliable medium hold for flexible styling without stiffness.
• Delivers a medium shine finish for a natural, healthy-looking appearance.
• Offers easy application and washes out effortlessly.

Pros:
– (Potentially) offers the beloved performance of the original formula.
– Pliable hold and natural shine.
– Easy to use and wash out.

Cons:
– Significant risk of inconsistent quality due to older stock.
– Manufacturer does not guarantee quality.
– May not perform as expected if the product is old or degraded.

Best for: Very dedicated fans of the original formula who are aware of the risks involved with purchasing older stock, seeking its specific pliable hold and shine.

User feedback summary: While some users fondly recall the original’s excellent performance, many reviews for this “old version” express frustration over inconsistent product quality and effectiveness due to its age.

Harry’s Taming Hair Cream for Men

Harry’s Taming Hair Cream is a fantastic option for guys who struggle with unruly, thick, coarse, or curly hair and want a styling product that truly tames without making it stiff or sticky. This cream provides a soft, conditioning hold that feels incredibly lightweight. It’s designed to give a natural finish, keeping your hair looking effortlessly smooth and polished without weighing it down. I really appreciate that it doesn’t leave any greasy residue, and the subtle scent with hints of coconut and calming herbs is a pleasant, understated bonus.

• Provides a soft, conditioning hold that tames unruly hair.
• Never feels stiff or sticky.
• Designed for thick, coarse, or curly hair.
• Keeps hair looking effortlessly smooth without weighing it down.
• Features a subtle scent with hints of coconut and calming herbs.

Pros:
– Excellent for taming and smoothing thick, coarse, or curly hair.
– Leaves hair feeling soft and natural.
– Lightweight and non-greasy.
– Subtle and appealing scent.

Cons:
– Soft hold may not be enough for highly structured styles.
– Not suitable for those seeking high shine or very strong hold.

Best for: Taming thick, coarse, or curly hair for a smooth, natural look with a light, conditioning hold.

User feedback summary: Users with textured or unruly hair frequently commend its ability to control frizz and provide a soft, natural finish without any heavy feel or residue.

Helpful Comparison Insights

When you’re choosing the best men’s hair cream, it really comes down to what kind of hair you have and the style you’re going for.

If you’re after a classic, high-shine, slick-back look, Brylcreem 3-in-1 Original High Shine is your go-to. It offers that traditional glossy finish and a light hold. For a more natural, flexible finish with medium shine, Cremo Hair Styling Cream and American Crew Men’s Hair Forming Cream are excellent choices, with Cremo being a bit more reworkable throughout the day.

For those needing stronger hold and significant texture, Tea Tree Shaping Cream is a top contender, delivering pliable yet long-lasting shape. If you need high hold with high shine and frizz control, especially for defined looks, American Crew Men’s Fiber Cream will be your best bet.

Guys with curly, wavy, or thick hair have some great options for taming and defining. Suavecito Hair Cream and Harry’s Taming Hair Cream both excel at this, offering soft, natural holds that enhance your natural texture without stiffness. Suavecito brings a classic barbershop scent and easy wash-out, while Harry’s is particularly good for truly unruly hair with a subtle, soothing scent. Rocky Mountain Barber Company Styling Hair Cream also shines here, offering a light, reworkable hold with nourishing oils for all hair lengths and a fresh mint scent.

Finally, for flexible, medium-hold styles with a low, natural shine, Redken Brews Cream Pomade is a fantastic, non-flaking option perfect for modern pompadours. It adds volume without feeling heavy. Just be wary of the American Crew Men’s Hair Forming Cream (OLD VERSION); while the original formula was great, the inconsistent quality of older stock makes it a risky purchase.

Ultimately, whether you prioritize hold, shine, conditioning benefits, or a specific hair type solution, there’s a men’s hair cream on this list that’s likely perfect for you.

Final Verdict

After trying out these different men’s hair creams, it’s clear there’s no single “best” for everyone. Your ideal choice really hinges on your hair type, desired hold, and preferred finish.

For a natural, flexible look that you can easily tweak all day, I often reach for Cremo Hair Styling Cream. It’s just so versatile and never feels heavy. If my hair needs a bit more definition and a stronger, yet still flexible, hold, Tea Tree Shaping Cream is usually my pick for its texture-enhancing abilities.

When I’m aiming for that classic, slick-back sheen, nothing beats the nostalgia and performance of Brylcreem. And for my friends with thicker or curlier hair who want control without stiffness, both Harry’s Taming Hair Cream and Suavecito Hair Cream consistently get rave reviews for making hair look naturally smooth and defined.

Don’t be afraid to experiment! Start with what best matches your primary need – whether it’s high shine, a natural look, or frizz control – and you’ll soon discover your own best men’s hair cream to keep your style on point.

Comprehensive FAQ Section

Q1: What exactly is men’s hair cream, and how does it differ from gel or pomade?
A1: Men’s hair cream is a water-based styling product known for providing a natural look with a flexible hold and often a subtle shine. Unlike gels, it rarely hardens or makes your hair crunchy, and it’s generally much lighter. Compared to pomades, which typically offer stronger hold and higher shine (or a matte, waxy finish), creams are usually softer, more conditioning, and give a more natural feel to your hair. The focus of the best men’s hair cream is often on conditioning and a natural finish.

Q2: How do I apply hair cream for the best results?
A2: Generally, you want to start with a dime-sized amount (you can always add more if needed!). Rub the cream thoroughly between your palms until it’s evenly distributed. Then, apply it to towel-dried, slightly damp hair for most natural looks and flexible holds. For more defined styles or to tame frizz, some creams work well on dry hair too. Work it from back to front, roots to tips, ensuring even coverage. Style as desired with your fingers for a loose look or a comb for more polish.

Q3: Is hair cream suitable for all hair types?
A3: Yes, one of the biggest benefits of men’s hair cream is its versatility. There are creams specifically formulated for fine hair (like Brylcreem, which adds body), thick or coarse hair (like Harry’s Taming Hair Cream), and even curly or wavy hair (like Suavecito or Rocky Mountain Barber Company, which enhance natural patterns and control frizz). It’s all about finding the right cream with the right hold and finish for your specific hair needs.

Q4: Will hair cream make my hair look greasy or stiff?
A4: The good news is, quality hair creams are designed to avoid this! Most modern men’s hair creams offer a natural finish with medium to low shine (or even high shine that looks healthy, not greasy) and provide flexible hold without stiffness. If your hair feels greasy, you might be using too much product. If it feels stiff, you might be using a cream with too strong a hold for your preference, or it might be a product more akin to a gel.

Q5: Can I use hair cream if I have a sensitive scalp or allergies?
A5: Many hair creams are formulated with gentle ingredients, and some, like Rocky Mountain Barber Company’s cream, focus on natural oils and no artificial fragrances. If you have a sensitive scalp or allergies, always check the ingredient list for potential irritants. Opt for alcohol-free formulas (like Brylcreem) as alcohol can dry out the scalp. It’s always a good idea to do a patch test on a small area of skin before full application.

Q6: How long does the hold from hair cream typically last?
A6: The hold duration of men’s hair cream varies depending on the product’s specific formulation and the amount you use. Most creams offer an all-day hold for flexible, natural styles, especially those with medium hold like Cremo or American Crew Forming Cream. Creams offering lighter holds (like Suavecito) are great for keeping hair soft and tame, but might need a refresh if you’re very active. Products like Tea Tree Shaping Cream are known for their long-lasting, pliable hold.

Q7: Can hair cream be used to add volume to fine hair?
A7: Absolutely! Many hair creams are excellent for adding body and making fine hair look thicker without weighing it down. Brylcreem, for example, is specifically noted for adding body to fine hair. When applying, focus on working the product into the roots and then through the lengths to maximize volume. Using a blow dryer on a low setting after applying can also help create more lift. Finding the best men’s hair cream for volume will make a noticeable difference.