Best Tires for Tesla with 5 Top Picks

Finding the right tires for your Tesla can feel overwhelming. This guide cuts through the confusion, offering detailed reviews of five popular options, covering everything from compact spares to performance tires and even stylish valve caps. We’ll help you weigh the pros and cons to find the best fit for your needs and budget, whether you’re looking for a reliable spare, a replacement tire, or just some snazzy accessories.

IMAGE	PRODUCT NAME	AMAZON LINK
	Modern Spare – Fits 2020-2026 Tesla Model Y – Compact…	View on Amazon
	Modern Spare – Fits 2017-2025 Tesla Model 3 – Compact…	View on Amazon
	GO-UPP 4PCS Copper Car Wheel Tires Valve Stem Caps for…	View on Amazon
	Toyo Tires PXAS 235/40R19 96Y XL	View on Amazon
	21″x10.5″ Reconditioned OEM Rear Wheel Rim For Tesla Model…	View on Amazon

1. Modern Spare – Fits 2020-2026 Tesla Model Y – Compact Spare Tire Kit

This isn’t your grandma’s donut spare. The Modern Spare is a purpose-built, lightweight alloy spare designed specifically for the Tesla Model Y. It’s engineered for compatibility, offering a better driving experience than the standard temporary spare. The kit often includes a jack and tools, making roadside repairs less stressful.

• Key Features:

  • Model-specific design for Tesla Model Y (2020-2026)
  • Lightweight aluminum alloy wheel
  • Includes a T145/85R18 radial tire
  • Complete tire changing kit available (jack, wrench, etc.)
  • Optional Ultra-Kit with safety accessories (wheel chocks, vest, triangles)

• Pros:

  • Superior to standard temporary spares
  • Convenient all-in-one kit option
  • Enhanced safety features with Ultra-Kit

• Cons:

  • Relatively expensive compared to a basic donut spare
  • Only fits specific Tesla Model Y years

• User Feedback Summary: Users praise the quality, ease of use, and peace of mind provided by having a proper spare. The Ultra-Kit is a popular add-on for increased safety.

• **

**

2. Modern Spare – Fits 2017-2025 Tesla Model 3 – Compact Spare Tire Kit

The Modern Spare for the Model 3 mirrors the quality and design of its Model Y counterpart. It offers the same benefits of a properly engineered spare tire, making it a worthwhile investment for Tesla Model 3 owners who want to avoid the limitations of a temporary spare.

• Key Features:

  • Model-specific design for Tesla Model 3 (2017-2025)
  • Lightweight aluminum alloy wheel
  • Includes a T135/80/R18 radial tire
  • Complete tire changing kit available
  • Optional Ultra-Kit with safety accessories

• Pros:

  • Designed for Model 3’s specific requirements
  • Improved handling compared to a standard temporary spare
  • Comprehensive kit options available

• Cons:

  • Price point is higher than basic temporary spares
  • Year-specific compatibility

• User Feedback Summary: Similar positive feedback to the Model Y version, emphasizing the improved driving experience and the convenience of the included tools.

• **

**

3. GO-UPP 4PCS Copper Car Wheel Tires Valve Stem Caps for Tesla

These aren’t performance tires, but they are a small detail that can make a difference. These valve stem caps offer a touch of style and protection for your Tesla’s wheels.

• Key Features:

  • Universal fit for various Tesla models
  • Made of durable zinc alloy
  • Prevents water and dust from entering the valve

• Pros:

  • Adds a bit of visual flair
  • Protects the valve stems from the elements

• Cons:

  • Primarily cosmetic; doesn’t impact performance
  • Requires occasional cleaning to prevent corrosion

• User Feedback Summary: Users generally appreciate the look and the added protection, but some note the need for regular cleaning.

• **

**

4. Toyo Tires PXAS 235/40R19 96Y XL

Toyo Tires are a reputable brand known for quality and performance. This specific tire (235/40R19 96Y XL) is a high-performance option, but remember to always check your Tesla’s recommended tire size before purchasing.

• Key Features:

  • High-performance tire
  • Made in Japan

• Pros:

  • Good handling and grip (depending on the application)
  • Reputable brand

• Cons:

  • Price can be higher than other options
  • Specific size; confirm compatibility with your Tesla model

• User Feedback Summary: Feedback varies depending on the application and driving conditions, but Toyo generally receives positive reviews for its performance tires.

• **

**

5. 21″x10.5″ Reconditioned OEM Rear Wheel Rim For Tesla Model Y

If you need to replace a damaged wheel, a reconditioned OEM rim can be a cost-effective solution. This option is specifically for the rear of a Tesla Model Y. Remember to verify the fitment with your car’s specifications.

• Key Features:

  • Reconditioned OEM Tesla Model Y rear wheel rim
  • Direct fit replacement
  • Compatible with existing TPMS sensors and other components

• Pros:

  • Cost-effective compared to a new wheel
  • Guaranteed fitment (if verified)

• Cons:

  • “Reconditioned” status means it’s not brand new
  • Does NOT include tire, TPMS sensors, or other accessories

• User Feedback Summary: Users report generally positive experiences with the reconditioned rims, particularly appreciating the cost savings. However, careful verification of compatibility is crucial.

• **

**

Practical Buying Advice

Before purchasing any tire or wheel, ALWAYS consult your Tesla’s owner’s manual to confirm the correct size and specifications. Factor in your driving style and conditions when choosing tires. If you’re unsure, consult with a tire professional.

Final Verdict

The “best” tire for your Tesla depends entirely on your needs. The Modern Spare kits are excellent for peace of mind, while the Toyo tires offer performance. The reconditioned rim is a budget-friendly option for wheel replacements. Always prioritize safety and compatibility when making your decision.

FAQ

Q: What is the importance of using the correct tire size for my Tesla?
A: Using the incorrect tire size can affect your Tesla’s handling, speedometer accuracy, and potentially damage other components. Always adhere to the manufacturer’s recommendations.

Q: How often should I rotate my Tesla’s tires?
A: Consult your owner’s manual for the recommended tire rotation schedule. Typically, it’s every 5,000-8,000 miles.

Q: Can I use all-season tires on my Tesla year-round?
A: It depends on your climate. All-season tires are a good compromise for moderate climates but may not be ideal for extreme winter or summer conditions.

Q: How do I know when my tires need to be replaced?
A: Check your tire tread depth regularly using a tread depth gauge. If it falls below the legal limit, or if you notice significant wear or damage, it’s time for new tires.

Q: Are there any specific performance tires recommended for Teslas?
A: Many high-performance tire brands offer options suitable for Teslas. Research and choose tires with performance ratings that match your driving style and the capabilities of your Tesla model. Consult a tire professional for personalized recommendations.

Q: What is the best way to store my spare tire?
A: Store your spare tire in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight and extreme temperatures. If it’s a temporary spare, keep it inflated to the correct pressure.