Best Hair Ties for Thick Hair Featuring 9 Quality Options

As someone with a good amount of hair – thick, long, and sometimes a bit unruly – I know the struggle of finding a hair tie that actually works. We’ve all been there: a ponytail holder that snaps mid-workout, tugs mercilessly at your scalp, leaves a giant crease, or simply stretches out after a few uses, becoming utterly useless. It’s frustrating, and honestly, a bit painful. That’s why I took it upon myself to dive deep into the world of best hair ties for thick hair, putting 9 popular options to the test to see which ones truly stand up to the challenge.

IMAGE	PRODUCT NAME	AMAZON LINK
	100 Pcs Thick Seamless Brown Hair Ties, Ponytail Holders…	View on Amazon
	Kitsch Nylon Hair Ties No Damage – Stretchable Elastics…	View on Amazon
	Goody Ouchless Forever Hair Elastics, 10 Ct, Black,…	View on Amazon
	GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands -…	View on Amazon
	50PCS Black Hair Ties for Women, Cotton Seamless Hair…	View on Amazon
	L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders, Black, Set of…	View on Amazon
	GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics, Black, 10.0 Count,	View on Amazon
	Kitsch Spiral Ponytail Holders for Women – Waterproof Hair…	View on Amazon
	GOSICUKA 120 Pieces Black Hair Ties for Thick and Curly…	View on Amazon

In this guide, I’ll walk you through my findings, giving you a detailed look at each product’s benefits, features, and real-world performance. Whether you’re looking for everyday utility, something damage-free, or a hair tie that can withstand the most intense activities, I’ve got you covered. Get ready to discover your new go-to ponytail holders for thick hair that actually deliver on their promises.

1. 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Brown Hair Ties, Ponytail Holders…

When you need a solid, no-frills hair tie in bulk, these 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Brown Hair Ties are a fantastic option. I found them to be surprisingly resilient for their price point. They’re made from a high-elastic material that really holds up, stretching quite a bit without losing its shape instantly. The seamless design is a major plus, as it means less snagging and pulling on your strands, which is crucial for those of us with thick hair prone to breakage. These come in neutral colors, making them discreet and versatile for any outfit or hair color. They’re a workhorse for everyday ponytails, buns, or braids, whether you’re at the gym or just lounging around.

• Durable and Stretchy: High elastic thick material maintains hold.
• Seamless Design: Prevents snagging and hair damage.
• Bulk Pack: 100 pieces for long-lasting use.
• Versatile Colors: 5 neutral shades to match different hair types and styles.
• Great Elasticity: Stretches up to 9.8 inches without easily losing shape.

Pros:
– Excellent value for money.
– Gentle on hair thanks to the seamless design.
– Strong enough for daily use on thick hair.
– Neutral colors blend in easily.

Cons:
– May not offer the absolute tightest grip for extremely heavy, slippery hair.
– The “brown” color range might be too limited for some fashion preferences.

Best for: Everyday use, stocking up, those who prioritize value and seamless design.

User feedback summary: Many users appreciate the quantity and the fact that these ties don’t pull or snag. They’re frequently praised for their durability and how well they hold thick hair without feeling too tight.

2. Kitsch Nylon Hair Ties No Damage – Stretchable Elastics…

Kitsch has a reputation for quality, and these Nylon Hair Ties definitely live up to it. Designed with a super smooth finish, they truly glide through your hair, which means no annoying pulling or breakage – a huge win for anyone with thick hair. I noticed how securely they held my ponytail without feeling overly tight or leaving a dent. What’s even better is that Kitsch consciously created these from recycled materials, so you’re making an eco-friendly choice. They’re durable, versatile for all hair types (from fine to thick), and comfortable enough for all-day wear, whether you’re working out or heading to the office.

• Smooth Finish: Glides through hair, preventing pulling and snagging.
• Secure, Damage-Free Hold: Keeps styles in place without breakage.
• Eco-Friendly: Made from recycled materials.
• Versatile: Suitable for various hair types and styles (baby to adult).
• Classic Black: Timeless and blends seamlessly into any look.

Pros:
– Gentle on hair, significantly reducing damage.
– Provides a strong, secure hold without being too tight.
– Sustainable choice due to recycled materials.
– Comfortable for extended wear.

Cons:
– Higher price point per tie compared to bulk packs.
– Black color might not suit everyone’s aesthetic preference all the time.

Best for: Those seeking damage-free, eco-conscious hair ties with a reliable hold for everyday wear.

User feedback summary: Users consistently rave about the “no damage” aspect and the secure hold. They love that these ties don’t snag, even on wet hair, and that they’re a more sustainable option.

3. Goody Ouchless Forever Hair Elastics, 10 Ct, Black…

The Goody Ouchless Forever Hair Elastics are a personal favorite for their incredible durability. Goody claims these are “3X Stronger” than ordinary elastics, and I can attest to their robustness. The secret is a reinforced 16-strand inner core, which means they truly bounce back to their original shape, time after time. No more stretched-out, useless hair ties after a few uses! The seamless bead closure also adds to their longevity, preventing the common snapping issue. These offer a strong, all-day hold, making them ideal for everything from intense workouts to busy daily routines, all while being gentle on your hair and minimizing breakage.

• “Forever” Design: Retains shape and holds like new every time.
• 3X Stronger: Durable 16-strand inner core for enhanced strength.
• Seamless Bead Closure: Prevents snapping and increases longevity.
• No Damage: Provides a gentle, secure grip with less breakage.
• Versatile: Works for all hair types – thick, thin, curly, or straight.

Pros:
– Exceptional durability and elasticity retention.
– Very strong hold, perfect for active lifestyles.
– Minimizes hair damage and breakage.
– Reliable for long-term use, great value over time.

Cons:
– The “Forever” claim, while impressive, depends on individual use.
– Only comes in black in this specific pack.

Best for: Anyone needing exceptionally strong and durable hair ties that won’t stretch out or break easily, perfect for active individuals.

User feedback summary: Users love how long these last without stretching out or snapping. Many consider them a staple for heavy or thick hair due to their strong, yet ouchless, hold.

4. GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands -…

If you have seriously thick hair, the GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands are specifically engineered for you. These blonde hair bands boast “Ultimate Strength” and I found that they truly deliver a secure hold without causing damage. The patent-pending design is a game-changer for elasticity retention, promising to keep their stretch for over six months – which is practically unheard of! They’re incredibly adaptable, working beautifully across all textures, from sleek to curly, and on both dry and oily hair. The unique, professional-grade construction ensures your style stays put, while the non-slip function means fewer adjustments throughout the day.

• Ultimate Strength: Designed specifically for thick hair, providing secure hold.
• Long-Lasting Elasticity: Patent-pending design retains stretch for over 6 months.
• Hair Smoothing Essential: Adapts to all hair textures, from sleek to curly.
• Non-Slip: Keeps hair in place without constant readjustment.
• Trendy Design: Premium rubber band alternative with a reflective logo.

Pros:
– Specifically formulated and incredibly effective for very thick hair.
– Unmatched elasticity retention, offering long-term value.
– Prevents hair damage and creates a smooth finish.
– Strong, reliable, non-slip hold.

Cons:
– Premium price point for a smaller quantity.
– Might be too robust for those with medium-thick hair or who prefer a looser hold.

Best for: Individuals with exceptionally thick or bulky hair who need maximum strength and long-lasting elasticity.

User feedback summary: Thick-haired users consistently praise these for their ability to hold heavy hair without slipping or breaking. They often mention the impressive durability and the lack of damage compared to other brands.

5. 50PCS Black Hair Ties for Women, Cotton Seamless Hair…

For a blend of comfort, stretch, and a gentle touch, these 50PCS Black Hair Ties are a solid choice. What sets them apart is their soft cotton material, combined with a seamless design. This means they’re incredibly gentle on your hair, significantly reducing the chances of snagging, pulling, or leaving creases. I found them to be highly elastic, able to hold a ponytail firmly without feeling restrictive or causing headaches. The simple black design is timeless and versatile, easily matching any outfit or hairstyle. They’re a great everyday option, offering both comfort and reliable hold for various occasions.

• Stretchy and Firm: High elastic material holds hair securely without loosening.
• No Hair Damage: Seamless design and soft cotton prevent snagging or pulling.
• Lasting Fashion: Simple design for a classic look.
• Simple Color: Black color easily matches any style or outfit.
• Comfortable: Gentle enough for all-day wear.

Pros:
– Very gentle on hair due to soft cotton and seamless construction.
– Good elasticity and firm hold.
– Economical 50-piece pack.
– Comfortable for daily wear, minimizes headaches.

Cons:
– Cotton material might absorb some moisture, making them less ideal for swimming.
– May not be as robust as some heavy-duty elastic options for extremely active use.

Best for: Daily wear, those seeking gentle, comfortable, and damage-free hair ties with a good stretch.

User feedback summary: Users frequently comment on the softness and comfort of these ties. They appreciate that they don’t pull hair and are effective for securing ponytails without feeling too tight.

6. L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders, Black, Set of…

The L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders are often considered a cult favorite, and after trying them, I can see why. These aren’t your average elastics; they feature a braided polyester band with a strong elastic core, designed specifically to deliver a stay-put hold for even the heaviest ponytails, top knots, and buns. I was impressed by their ability to provide a secure, slip-free fit without any snagging or creasing – a common issue with other ties. The thicker, glossy black finish gives them a more polished and luxurious feel, making them a great option not just for function but also for style. They’re durable and comfortable, truly living up to their reputation for all-day hold.

• Braided Polyester Bands: Durable and stylish, specifically for thick hair.
• Strong, Stay-Put Hold: Durable elastic core secures heavy styles.
• Comfortable, Damage-Free: No-pull, slip-free fit prevents snagging or creasing.
• Polished Finish: Glossy black for a timeless, elegant look.
• Cult Favorite: Known worldwide for comfort, durability, and all-day hold.

Pros:
– Exceptional grip and hold for very thick or heavy hair.
– Prevents creases and hair damage effectively.
– Luxurious feel and appearance.
– Very durable and long-lasting.

Cons:
– Higher price point for a set of 8.
– Thicker band might be too noticeable for those who prefer a more discreet look.

Best for: Individuals with thick, heavy hair who want a secure, damage-free, and stylish hold for polished looks.

User feedback summary: These are highly praised for their ability to hold thick hair all day without slipping or causing headaches. Users also love that they don’t stretch out quickly and look much nicer than standard hair ties.

7. GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics, Black, 10.0 Count

For those of us with a serious amount of hair, the GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics are a must-try. As the name suggests, these are specifically designed to be larger and more robust than standard elastics, making them perfect for voluminous hair. The “no metal” design means you don’t have to worry about snagging or pulling on your hair, a common complaint with many traditional hair ties. Goody boasts “10x More Ponytails per elastic,” highlighting their impressive durability and ability to maintain their shape and elasticity over time. I found them to provide a comfortable, yet very secure, hold that lasts throughout the day, even with heavy hair.

• XL & Extra Thick: Designed for voluminous and heavy hair.
• Ouchless No Metal: Prevents snagging and hair damage.
• 10x More Ponytails: Claims superior durability and elasticity retention.
• Secure Hold: Keeps hair comfortably in place all day.
• Trusted Brand: Over 100 years of hair styling experience.

Pros:
– Excellent for extremely thick or long hair that overwhelms standard ties.
– Gentle on hair with no metal parts.
– Very durable and holds shape well.
– Provides a comfortable, secure hold.

Cons:
– The “XL” size might be too large for some with moderately thick hair.
– Comes in a standard black color, limiting aesthetic options.

Best for: Individuals with very long, thick, or voluminous hair who need an extra-large, extra-strong, and damage-free solution.

User feedback summary: Users with very thick hair consistently report that these are the only hair ties that can truly hold their hair securely and comfortably without snapping or slipping. They appreciate the larger size and no-metal design.

8. Kitsch Spiral Ponytail Holders for Women – Waterproof Hair…

The Kitsch Spiral Ponytail Holders are a game-changer for avoiding that dreaded ponytail bump and hair headaches. The unique spiral design evenly distributes pressure across a larger surface area of your hair, which is fantastic for both comfort and preventing creases. As someone who often gets headaches from tight ponytails, I found these to be incredibly comfortable for all-day wear. They’re made of smooth plastic, so they don’t tangle or cause breakage, even on wet hair, making them perfect for swimming or showering. Plus, they double as cute wrist accessories! If they stretch out, a quick soak in warm water brings them back to size.

• Spiral Design: Prevents ponytail bumps and headaches by spreading pressure.
• No Tangles or Breakage: Smooth plastic glides through hair.
• Waterproof and Hygienic: Non-absorbent, ideal for wet conditions.
• Cute On Your Wrist: Doubles as a stylish bracelet.
• Resizable: Soak in warm water to restore elasticity if stretched.

Pros:
– Effectively prevents hair creases and headaches.
– Gentle on hair, no snagging or breakage.
– Excellent for active lifestyles and water activities.
– Versatile and stylish.

Cons:
– May not provide the absolute tightest, immovable grip compared to traditional elastics for very heavy hair.
– The “small” size might need to be wrapped more times for extremely thick hair.

Best for: Those who want to avoid creases, headaches, and damage, especially for active use or in wet environments.

User feedback summary: Users adore these for preventing creases and headaches, calling them incredibly comfortable. They’re particularly popular among those with curly or textured hair who want a gentle, non-damaging hold.

9. GOSICUKA 120 Pieces Black Hair Ties for Thick and Curly…

Finally, the GOSICUKA 120 Pieces Black Hair Ties offer another excellent bulk option, specifically catering to thick and curly hair. These ties are 4mm thick and 2 inches in diameter, making them substantial enough to handle a lot of hair. I found them to be incredibly elastic – they stretch easily up to 10.6 inches and quickly resume their original shape, meaning they hold your hair tightly without losing their grip. The soft, no-crease elastic material is a big plus, providing a secure hold without causing damage or leaving dents in your hair. With 120 pieces, this pack is incredibly economical, ensuring you’ll have plenty of reliable hair ties on hand for any occasion.

• High Elasticity: Stretches easily and resumes quickly, providing a tight hold.
• Thick and Wide: 4mm thick, 2″ diameter, suitable for medium to thick hair.
• Bulk Pack: 120 pieces for long-term use and sharing.
• Strong and Durable: Stretches up to 10.6″ without breaking easily.
• Soft, No Crease: Secure hold without damage or dents.

Pros:
– Great value with a large quantity.
– Very elastic and durable, holding hair tightly.
– Gentle on hair, preventing creases and damage.
– Suitable for various thick hair styles.

Cons:
– May feel slightly less premium than some branded options.
– Only available in black, which might not always match every outfit.

Best for: Those with thick and curly hair looking for an economical bulk pack of strong, elastic, and damage-free hair ties.

User feedback summary: Users with thick and curly hair are very impressed by the strong hold and durability of these ties. They particularly like that they don’t break easily and are gentle enough not to cause damage.

Helpful Comparison Insights

Navigating the world of best hair ties for thick hair can feel overwhelming, but a few key distinctions can help.

When it comes to sheer durability and preventing stretching out, the Goody Ouchless Forever and GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands are standouts. Goody’s 16-strand core truly makes a difference, while GIMME’s patent-pending design specifically addresses elasticity retention for over six months. If you’re tired of constantly replacing stretched-out ties, these are worth the investment.

For those whose priority is damage-free hold and preventing creases, the Kitsch Nylon Hair Ties and the Kitsch Spiral Ponytail Holders excel. Kitsch Nylon’s smooth finish and recycled material make them gentle, while the Spiral ties are a revelation for avoiding bumps and headaches. The L. Erickson Grab & Go also deserves a special mention here for its no-pull, slip-free design that minimizes creasing while offering a very strong hold.

If budget and bulk quantity are your main concerns, the 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Brown Hair Ties and GOSICUKA 120 Pieces Black Hair Ties offer fantastic value. Both provide a high quantity of reliable, seamless hair ties that are great for everyday use without breaking the bank. The 50PCS Black Hair Ties also fall into this category, offering a softer, cotton-based option.

Finally, for extremely thick or voluminous hair, the GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics and GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands are specifically designed to tackle the challenge. Their larger size and enhanced strength ensure your heavy hair stays put all day.

Remember, the “best” tie often depends on your specific needs: whether it’s a tight gym hold, a gentle all-day tie, or a bulk option for everyday use.

Final Verdict: My Top Picks for Thick Hair

After putting these hair ties for thick hair through their paces, it’s clear there’s no single “best” option for everyone, but I can definitely highlight a few personal favorites based on different needs:

• For the Ultimate Workhorse (Durability & Strength): The Goody Ouchless Forever Hair Elastics are incredibly impressive. They just don’t quit. If you need a tie that can withstand anything and bounce back, these are it.
• For Damage-Free Comfort (No Creases or Headaches): The Kitsch Spiral Ponytail Holders are a revelation. They seriously prevent bumps and are so comfortable, making them perfect for all-day wear without the usual tight ponytail discomfort.
• For Everyday Value & Gentle Hold: The 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Brown Hair Ties offer an unbeatable combination of quantity, gentleness, and reliable hold for daily life without fuss.
• For Seriously Thick & Heavy Hair (Unwavering Grip): The GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands truly stand out. They are engineered to keep even the most voluminous hair securely in place, proving their worth for those who struggle with slippage.

Ultimately, investing in a few different types of ponytail holders for thick hair might be the best approach. Keep a durable Goody Forever for workouts, a gentle Kitsch Spiral for casual days, and a bulk pack for everyday convenience. Your hair (and your scalp!) will thank you for it.

Comprehensive FAQ Section

Q1: What makes a hair tie “good” for thick hair?
A: Best hair ties for thick hair typically feature high elasticity, strong material (often nylon, braided polyester, or a thick elastic core), and a seamless design. They should be able to wrap around thick hair multiple times without snapping or stretching out, provide a secure hold without slipping, and be gentle enough to prevent damage or creases.

Q2: Why do my hair ties always snap or stretch out quickly?
A: This is a common issue for those with thick hair! Most standard hair ties aren’t designed to withstand the tension and volume of thick hair. Look for ties specifically marketed for thick hair, often labeled “heavy duty,” “extra thick,” or with reinforced cores, like the Goody Ouchless Forever or GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands.

Q3: Are spiral hair ties effective for thick hair?
A: Yes, absolutely! Kitsch Spiral Ponytail Holders are excellent for thick hair because their unique spiral design distributes pressure more evenly. This helps prevent headaches and those annoying creases often left by traditional elastic ties, while still offering a secure hold.

Q4: How can I prevent my hair tie from damaging my thick hair?
A: To minimize damage, opt for damage-free hair ties with a smooth, seamless design (like the Kitsch Nylon Hair Ties or the 50PCS Black Cotton Seamless Hair Ties). Avoid ties with metal clamps. Don’t pull your ponytails too tight, and try not to wear your hair in the same tight style every day. Spiral ties are also a great option for reducing stress on your strands.

Q5: What’s the best type of hair tie for workouts if I have thick hair?
A: For intense workouts, you need a strong, secure hold that won’t slip. The Goody Ouchless Forever Hair Elastics and GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands are fantastic choices due to their superior strength and elasticity retention. Spiral ties can also be great for comfort and preventing headaches during activity.

Q6: Can I use regular hair ties if I have thick hair, or do I need special ones?
A: While you can use regular hair ties, you’ll likely find them snapping, stretching out, or failing to hold your hair securely. Investing in best hair ties for thick hair specifically designed for your hair type will save you frustration, money, and potential hair damage in the long run.

Q7: How do I choose between different materials like nylon, cotton, or braided elastic for my thick hair?
A: Each material has benefits:
* Nylon (like Kitsch Nylon) is smooth, durable, and often used in seamless designs to prevent snagging.
* Cotton (like 50PCS Black Cotton) is very soft and gentle, great for minimizing damage and comfort, but might not be as robust or waterproof as other options.
* Braided Polyester/Thick Elastic Core (like L. Erickson or Goody Forever) offers exceptional strength and hold, making them ideal for heavy or very active hair, but can sometimes feel thicker. Your choice depends on your priority: gentleness, strength, or specific use cases.