Best Goat Milk Options for Soap Making

When I first started dabbling in soap making, I was immediately drawn to the idea of crafting luxurious, skin-nourishing bars. And what better ingredient to achieve that than goat milk? I quickly learned that goat milk soap isn’t just a trend; it’s renowned for its moisturizing properties, gentle touch, and creamy lather, making it a favorite for sensitive skin. But standing in front of the aisle (or, more realistically, browsing online), I soon realized the sheer number of “best goat milk options for soap making” available. It can be a little overwhelming to figure out which melt and pour goat milk soap base will give you the best results for your unique projects.

IMAGE	PRODUCT NAME	AMAZON LINK
	Our Earth’s Secrets Goats Milk – 2 Lbs Melt and…	View on Amazon
	Goat Milk Soap Making Kit for Adults – 2lb Pre-Cut…	View on Amazon
	Primal Elements Goat Milk Soap Base – Moisturizing Melt…	View on Amazon
	Skin Said Yes 5Lb Goat Milk Soap Base – SLS/SLES…	View on Amazon
	Prime Creations Soap Base for soap making supplies melt…	View on Amazon
	velona 2 LB – Goats Milk Soap Base Pre-Cut Cubes…	View on Amazon
	velona 5 LB – Goats MILK Soap Base SLS/SLES free…	View on Amazon

That’s where this guide comes in. I’ve rolled up my sleeves, metaphorically speaking, to explore some of the most popular and highly-regarded goat milk soap bases on the market. Whether you’re a complete beginner looking for an all-inclusive kit or a seasoned crafter hunting for a premium bulk option, I’ll walk you through seven reliable goat milk options, breaking down their features, benefits, and best uses. My goal is to give you the insights you need to confidently choose the perfect goat milk base for your next soap making adventure.

Product Reviews: Finding Your Ideal Goat Milk Soap Base

Here are my detailed reviews of some fantastic goat milk soap base options for your crafting needs:

Our Earth’s Secrets Goats Milk – 2 Lbs Melt and Pour Soap Base

This 2-pound block from Our Earth’s Secrets is often a go-to for many crafters, and it’s easy to see why. It offers a straightforward, reliable melt and pour experience with a good balance of beneficial ingredients. The inclusion of 10% real goat’s milk is a significant plus, contributing to that signature creamy feel and skin-softening benefits. It’s a solid choice that melts down smoothly and consistently, making it ideal for creating beautiful, moisturizing soap bars. The ingredients list is transparent, showing a blend of coconut oil, palm oil, and safflower oil, along with glycerin for added moisture, and oat protein for conditioning. It’s also proudly made in the USA and free from soybean.

• Key Features:

  • Contains 10% real goat’s milk
  • Includes coconut, palm, and safflower oils
  • Glycerine and oat protein for skin benefits
  • Soybean free
  • Made in the USA
  • Titanium Dioxide for an opaque finish

• Pros:

  • Very easy to melt and pour for beginners
  • Produces a creamy, gentle lather
  • Good balance of natural oils
  • High-quality base for a reasonable price
  • Slightly opaque finish which helps with color stability

• Cons:

  • Contains palm oil, which some users prefer to avoid for sustainability reasons
  • The opaque nature means it’s not suitable for transparent soap designs

• Best for: Beginners and intermediate crafters looking for a reliable, easy-to-use, and moisturizing goat milk soap base.

User feedback summary: Many users appreciate how smoothly this base melts and its consistent performance. They often highlight the creamy texture and gentle feel it gives to their finished soaps, noting it’s a great starting point for custom creations.

Goat Milk Soap Making Kit for Adults – 2lb Pre-Cut

If you’re just starting out or looking for a fun, creative activity with family, this all-in-one goat milk soap making kit is fantastic. It takes all the guesswork out of gathering supplies. The 2lbs of goat milk soap base comes pre-cut into small, manageable pieces, which is incredibly convenient and safe, especially if kids are involved (with adult supervision, of course). What really sets this kit apart are the plentiful customization options: six vibrant color dyes and six rich fragrances are included, alongside reusable silicone molds, a pitcher, and even soap boxes for gifting. It truly offers a complete experience from start to finish.

• Key Features:

  • All-in-one DIY kit with everything included
  • 2lbs pre-cut goat milk soap base for easy handling
  • 6 durable silicone molds
  • 6 vibrant color dyes and 6 unique fragrances
  • Comes with a spatula, pitcher, and soap boxes
  • Perfect for beginners, kids, and family activities

• Pros:

  • Extremely beginner-friendly, no extra supplies needed
  • Pre-cut base is safer and easier to measure
  • Offers extensive customization with included dyes and scents
  • Great for gifts or fun family bonding time
  • Reusable molds add value

• Cons:

  • Might be a bit more expensive per ounce of base compared to buying just the base
  • Included fragrances and dyes might not be “natural” enough for purists
  • The base quantity is limited to 2lbs

• Best for: Absolute beginners, families with children, anyone looking for an all-inclusive gift or activity kit, or those who want to experiment with different colors and scents without buying them separately.

User feedback summary: Customers rave about the convenience and completeness of this kit. They often mention how easy it is for kids to participate and how satisfying it is to create unique, personalized soaps right out of the box.

Primal Elements Goat Milk Soap Base – Moisturizing Melt

Primal Elements offers a straightforward and highly versatile goat milk soap base that’s a staple for many crafters. This solid soap base is designed to be easily melted, mixed, and molded, making it incredibly adaptable for various projects. It’s an excellent choice if you already have your own collection of colorants, fragrances, and molds, as it provides a clean canvas for your creativity. The focus here is on ease of use and the ability to produce a foaming, moisturizing soap that the whole family will enjoy. It simplifies the soap making process down to its core: melt, personalize, and pour.

• Key Features:

  • Solid, easy-to-melt soap base
  • Designed for custom coloring and fragrances
  • Creates a foaming soap
  • Great for creating custom bars and shapes
  • Suitable for family activities

• Pros:

  • Very simple to use, ideal for basic melt and pour projects
  • Versatile for adding your own preferred additives
  • Produces a good lather
  • A dependable base for everyday soap making

• Cons:

  • Fewer specific ingredient details provided compared to some other brands
  • Requires purchasing additional supplies like colors and scents separately
  • Comes as a solid block, requiring cutting before melting

• Best for: Crafters who already have a collection of soap making supplies, those looking for a basic yet reliable goat milk melt and pour base, and individuals who prioritize customization.

User feedback summary: Makers consistently praise this base for its effortless melting and its ability to blend seamlessly with various additives. They find it to be a dependable foundation for their unique soap creations, producing a satisfying lather.

Skin Said Yes 5Lb Goat Milk Soap Base – SLS/SLES Free

For those who prioritize ethically sourced and skin-loving ingredients, the Skin Said Yes 5Lb Goat Milk Soap Base is a standout. This base boasts a heritage of over 150 years of refinement, and it’s dermatologically checked, making it exceptionally safe for all skin types, including dry or aging skin. What truly impresses me are its ingredients: rich in organic Mediterranean olive oil and coconut oil, and notably free from palm oil, SLES, parabens, and harsh ingredients. It’s also packaged in nature-friendly, recyclable materials that meet FSC standards, reflecting a strong commitment to environmental responsibility. As a bonus, it includes a recipe book to spark your creativity!

• Key Features:

  • Dermatologically checked, safe for all skin types
  • Rich in organic Mediterranean olive oil and coconut oil
  • Free from palm oil, SLES, parabens, and harsh ingredients
  • Nature-friendly, recyclable packaging (FSC standards)
  • Unscented, allowing for full customization
  • Includes a recipe book for inspiration
  • 5lb bulk size for extensive projects

• Pros:

  • Exceptional for sensitive skin due to gentle, organic ingredients
  • Strong ethical and environmental credentials (no palm oil, recyclable)
  • Deeply moisturizing and provides a lush lather
  • The included recipe book is a helpful guide for both beginners and pros
  • Unscented nature allows for true personalization

• Cons:

  • Might be a higher price point due to organic and ethical sourcing
  • Specific full ingredient list, while good, may contain less familiar chelating agents (Tetrasodium Glutamate Diacetate) for absolute purists

• Best for: Eco-conscious crafters, individuals with very sensitive or aging skin, those seeking high-quality organic ingredients, and bulk buyers who value ethical sourcing and dermatological safety.

User feedback summary: Crafters consistently highlight the luxurious feel and moisturizing benefits of soaps made with this base. They deeply appreciate the commitment to organic, ethical ingredients and the fact that it’s gentle enough for sensitive skin, often referring to it as a premium choice.

Prime Creations Soap Base for soap making supplies melt

Prime Creations offers a 5-pound bulk goat milk soap base that stands out for its commitment to natural, skin-friendly ingredients and user convenience. This soap base proudly states it’s GMO FREE, PARABEN FREE, CRUELTY FREE, SLES/SLS FREE, AND PALM OIL FREE, making it an excellent choice for those mindful about what goes onto their skin. It’s formulated with a high quantity of glycerin, ensuring a smooth melting and pouring experience, along with excellent moisturizing properties. A unique selling point is that the 5 pounds are divided into convenient 1-pound bars, simplifying portioning and storage. Plus, it comes with its own DIY recipe book, perfect for sparking new ideas.

• Key Features:

  • Skin safe and highly moisturizing
  • GMO FREE, PARABEN FREE, CRUELTY FREE, SLES/SLS FREE, PALM OIL FREE
  • 100% natural and premium high quality with high glycerin content
  • Pretested for smooth melting and pouring
  • 5 pounds divided into 1-pound bars for convenience
  • Includes a DIY recipe book with captivating recipes

• Pros:

  • Very comprehensive “free-from” list appeals to health-conscious consumers
  • Exceptional moisturizing benefits due to high glycerin content
  • Convenient pre-portioned 1-pound bars reduce waste and effort
  • Recipe book offers great value for inspiration
  • Excellent for personal use, gifts, or group activities

• Cons:

  • While “natural,” the full detailed ingredient list beyond the “free from” claims isn’t always immediately visible
  • Some may find the pre-cut bars slightly more expensive than a single large block if maximum bulk savings are the only goal

• Best for: Health-conscious crafters seeking a “free-from” base, those who value the convenience of pre-portioned blocks, and crafters looking for a high-quality, moisturizing base for bulk projects or gift-making.

User feedback summary: Users frequently praise the ease of melting and pouring, appreciating the consistent quality and moisturizing feel of the finished soaps. The pre-cut 1-pound bars are a common highlight, making projects much more manageable.

velona 2 LB – Goats Milk Soap Base Pre-Cut Cubes

Velona’s 2 Lb Goats Milk Soap Base comes in convenient pre-cut cubes, making your soap making process incredibly smooth and enjoyable from the start. This base is marketed as 100% Natural, Premium Quality, Non-GMO, Cruelty Free, Soy free, and SLS/SLES Free, aligning with many crafters’ desire for cleaner ingredients. Beyond its ethical claims, Velona emphasizes the inherent skin benefits of goat milk, such as alpha-hydroxy acids (like lactic acid) for gentle exfoliation and Vitamin A for skin repair and anti-aging properties. Its high glycerin content ensures a deeply moisturizing bar, perfect for creating personalized gifts or luxurious self-care items. Plus, it comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

• Key Features:

  • Pre-cut cubes for easy measurement and melting
  • 100% Natural, Premium Quality, Non-GMO, Cruelty Free, Soy free, SLS/SLES Free
  • High glycerin content for moisturizing
  • Highlights skin benefits of goat milk (alpha-hydroxy acids, Vitamin A)
  • Perfect for custom gifts
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

• Pros:

  • Extremely easy to use for beginners due to pre-cut cubes
  • Robust “free-from” list appeals to natural product enthusiasts
  • Emphasizes the direct skin benefits of goat milk
  • Guaranteed satisfaction offers peace of mind
  • Creates a smooth, young-looking skin feel

• Cons:

  • Full specific ingredient list beyond the “free from” claims could be more detailed
  • Only a 2lb quantity, so not ideal for very large-scale production

• Best for: Beginners, crafters who value convenience and natural ingredients, those focused on the specific skin-nourishing benefits of goat milk, and anyone looking to make custom gifts.

User feedback summary: Customers love the convenience of the pre-cut cubes, noting how much time and effort they save. Many also commend the moisturizing quality of the finished soap and appreciate the “free-from” claims that align with their preferences.

velona 5 LB – Goats MILK Soap Base SLS/SLES free

If you’re already a fan of Velona’s quality or simply need a larger quantity for your goat milk soap making projects, their 5 LB block is an excellent choice. This is the economical, bulk version of their popular base, offering the same SLS/SLES-free, 100% Natural, Non-GMO, Cruelty-Free, and Soy-free formulation that crafters appreciate. While it comes as a solid block rather than pre-cut cubes, it provides significant value for those planning larger batches or frequent soap production. You still get the benefit of goat milk’s alpha-hydroxy acids and Vitamin A for skin conditioning, along with a high glycerin content for moisture, ensuring your handmade soaps are both gentle and effective.

• Key Features:

  • 5 Lb bulk size for better value
  • SLS/SLES free, 100% Natural, Non-GMO, Cruelty Free, Soy free
  • High glycerin content for superior moisturizing
  • Formulated for smooth melting and pouring
  • Leverages goat milk’s skin-benefiting alpha-hydroxy acids and Vitamin A
  • Ideal for larger batches or frequent use

• Pros:

  • Excellent value for money in a larger quantity
  • Consistent, high-quality performance for reliable results
  • Retains all the skin-friendly and ethical benefits of the 2lb version
  • Perfect for experienced crafters or small businesses
  • Allows for maximum customization of bar size and shape

• Cons:

  • Comes as a solid block, requiring you to cut and portion it yourself
  • Might be too much for absolute beginners or those only making a few bars
  • Requires more storage space than smaller packs

• Best for: Experienced crafters, bulk buyers, small businesses, or anyone who frequently makes goat milk soap and appreciates the cost savings and consistent quality of a larger format.

User feedback summary: Loyal users of Velona find this 5lb option to be a fantastic bulk buy, offering the same reliable quality and moisturizing properties as the smaller sizes. They appreciate the cost-effectiveness for larger projects and the smooth texture it consistently produces.

Comparison Insights: Choosing Your Best Goat Milk Options for Soap Making

Navigating the various goat milk soap bases can feel like a puzzle, but understanding their differences helps significantly. If convenience and ease of use are your top priorities, especially as a beginner or for crafting with kids, the Goat Milk Soap Making Kit is hard to beat with its pre-cut base and all-inclusive supplies. Similarly, the velona 2 LB Pre-Cut Cubes offer that same convenient pre-cut format for quick, no-fuss projects.

For crafters who are deeply committed to ethical sourcing and skin-safe ingredients, Skin Said Yes and Prime Creations really shine. Skin Said Yes emphasizes its dermatological testing and includes organic olive and coconut oils, while being completely palm oil-free. Prime Creations also boasts a strong “free-from” list, including no palm oil, SLS/SLES, parabens, or GMOs, and offers the added convenience of 1-pound pre-portioned bars within its 5lb package. Velona also delivers with its SLS/SLES-free and cruelty-free claims across both its 2lb and 5lb options.

When value for money and bulk purchasing become important, the 5-pound options are your best bet. Both Skin Said Yes and Prime Creations offer excellent 5lb bases with strong ingredient ethics. The velona 5 LB provides a great cost-effective bulk option for those who already trust the brand’s quality and don’t mind cutting their own portions. For a dependable, general-purpose base that’s a bit more budget-friendly and still delivers on quality, Our Earth’s Secrets is a popular and well-regarded 2lb choice, though it does contain palm oil. The Primal Elements base is another great foundational option if you prefer to buy your additives separately and want a basic, solid base to work with.

Consider your crafting frequency, your sensitivity to certain ingredients, and whether you want an all-inclusive experience or prefer to be more selective with your additives.

Final Verdict: My Top Picks for Goat Milk Soap Bases

Making homemade goat milk soap is a rewarding experience, and having the right base makes all the difference. After reviewing these fantastic options, here are my final thoughts to help you make your best choice:

• Best Overall for Quality & Ethical Sourcing: The Skin Said Yes 5Lb Goat Milk Soap Base is a clear winner if you prioritize organic ingredients, dermatological safety, and a palm oil-free, environmentally conscious product. Its rich formula delivers outstanding moisturizing benefits.

• Best for Beginners & Gifting: For those just starting out or looking for a fun, complete project, the Goat Milk Soap Making Kit for Adults is unbeatable. It provides everything you need, takes the guesswork out, and makes for a fantastic gift or family activity.

• Best Value with Ethical Focus: If you’re buying in bulk but still want a strong “free-from” profile (including no palm oil and SLS/SLES), the Prime Creations Soap Base (5 Lb, pre-cut 1lb bars) offers incredible convenience and great value. The pre-portioned bars are a huge plus.

• Best for Everyday Reliable Crafting: The Our Earth’s Secrets Goats Milk – 2 Lbs Melt and Pour Soap Base is a fantastic choice for consistent, creamy results at a great price, making it a staple for many regular soap makers.

Ultimately, the “best” choice really depends on your personal needs, values, and how you plan to use your goat milk soap base. Happy crafting!

Comprehensive FAQ Section: Goat Milk Options for Soap Making

Q1: Why choose goat milk for soap making over other bases?
A: Goat milk is celebrated in soap making for its rich, creamy texture and skin-nourishing properties. It’s packed with vitamins (especially A), minerals, and alpha-hydroxy acids (like lactic acid), which can help gently exfoliate and moisturize the skin, leaving it feeling soft and smooth. Many people find goat milk soap to be particularly gentle and soothing for sensitive or dry skin.

Q2: What’s the main difference between melt and pour and cold process goat milk soap?
A: Melt and pour goat milk soap bases (like the ones reviewed here) are pre-made soaps that you simply melt down, add your desired colors and fragrances, and pour into molds. It’s a quick, easy, and safe method for beginners. Cold process soap making, on the other hand, involves creating soap from scratch using raw ingredients like oils, lye, and liquid goat milk. It’s a more advanced technique that requires safety precautions and a longer curing time, but it offers complete control over ingredients.

Q3: Are “SLS/SLES free” goat milk soap bases really better for my skin?
A: Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS) and Sodium Laureth Sulfate (SLES) are common surfactants that create lather, but some individuals find them irritating to their skin, potentially leading to dryness or redness. Opting for an SLS/SLES-free goat milk soap base can be beneficial if you have sensitive skin or prefer to avoid these ingredients, as they are often replaced with milder cleansing agents or rely more on the natural lather of glycerin and oils.

Q4: How do I add color and fragrance to my goat milk soap base?
A: It’s quite simple! Once your goat milk soap base is melted, you can stir in liquid soap dyes (specifically designed for soap making) for color. For fragrance, add essential oils or fragrance oils. Start with a small amount and gradually add more until you reach your desired intensity. Always follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for usage rates, especially for fragrance oils, to ensure skin safety. Mix gently to avoid introducing too many air bubbles.

Q5: How much goat milk soap base do I need for a project?
A: The amount of goat milk soap base you need depends on the size and number of soap bars you want to make, and the capacity of your molds. A good rule of thumb is that 1 pound (approximately 454 grams) of soap base will make about four to five standard 4oz soap bars. Always measure your molds by filling them with water and then weighing the water to get an accurate estimate of how much soap base you’ll need.

Q6: Can I make my own liquid goat milk soap from a melt and pour base?
A: Melt and pour soap bases are designed to create solid bar soaps. While some crafters experiment with dissolving small amounts of melt and pour soap into water to create a very basic liquid hand soap, it generally won’t have the same consistency, shelf life, or lathering properties as a commercially formulated liquid soap. For liquid goat milk soap, you would typically need a specialized liquid soap base or to undertake cold process liquid soap making from scratch.

Q7: What’s the shelf life of homemade goat milk soap made with a melt and pour base?
A: Homemade goat milk soap made from a melt and pour base generally has a good shelf life, typically around 1-2 years if stored properly. To maximize its longevity, keep your finished soap bars in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and humidity. Wrapping them tightly in plastic wrap or shrink wrap can also help protect them from moisture and preserve their scent.