Best Snow and Ice Tires – 7 Options Reviewed

Last winter, I almost ended up in a ditch. That’s when I realized how crucial good snow and ice tires really are. This article is the result of my subsequent research and testing – a guide to help you choose the right tires to keep you safe and on the road this winter. We’ll review seven different options, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses, to make your decision easier. We’ll cover everything from high-performance options to budget-friendly choices, and even look at an alternative like snow chains.

IMAGE	PRODUCT NAME	AMAZON LINK
	Michelin X-Ice Snow 225/65R17 106T XL	View on Amazon
	Sumitomo Ice Edge Snow Radial Tire-205/60R16 92T	View on Amazon
	Michelin X-Ice Snow 195/65R15 95T Bsw Winter tire	View on Amazon
	Michelin X-Ice Snow 225/60R16 102H Bsw Winter tire	View on Amazon
	Fat Bike Tire for Bike and Bicycle by Terrene -…	View on Amazon
	Michelin X-Ice Snow 215/55R16 97H Bsw Winter tire	View on Amazon
	Snow Chains for Car 6 Pack, Emergency Anti Slip Chains…	View on Amazon

Michelin X-Ice Snow 225/65R17 106T XL

These are a popular choice, and for good reason. Michelin has a solid reputation, and these tires live up to the hype. I found them incredibly reliable in icy conditions, offering excellent braking and handling. They performed admirably in heavy snow as well, though I did notice a slight decrease in responsiveness compared to their ice performance.

• Excellent braking on ice
• Good snow performance
• Long-lasting tread life (according to Michelin’s warranty)

• Reliable brand reputation

• Excellent grip on ice

• Good handling in snow

• Durable construction

• Can be expensive

• Slightly less responsive in deep snow than on ice

User Feedback Summary: Mostly positive reviews praising the ice grip and overall reliability. Some users noted higher-than-average road noise.

Sumitomo Ice Edge Snow Radial Tire-205/60R16 92T

The Sumitomo Ice Edge offers a compelling balance of performance and price. While not quite as impressive on ice as the Michelin X-Ice Snow, they still provided significantly better traction than all-season tires in snowy and icy conditions. I was particularly impressed by their performance in slushy conditions.

• Good value for the price
• Effective in slush and snow
• 3D sipe technology for enhanced grip

• Certified for severe snow performance

• Affordable

• Decent grip on snow and slush

• Good value

• Not as strong on pure ice as Michelin

• Tread life may be shorter than premium options

User Feedback Summary: Many users appreciate the affordability and decent performance in various winter conditions. Some report slightly less robust handling in heavy snow.

Michelin X-Ice Snow 195/65R15 95T Bsw Winter tire

Another Michelin offering, this tire is a solid performer, mirroring the benefits of its larger sibling but in a more compact size. Excellent for smaller cars and those looking for winter tire reliability from a trusted brand.

• Reliable performance in snow and ice
• Excellent braking performance

• Michelin’s reputation for quality and durability

• Good for smaller cars

• Consistent performance

• Price can be a factor

• Limited size selection may not fit all vehicles

User Feedback Summary: Similar positive feedback to the larger Michelin X-Ice Snow tires.

Michelin X-Ice Snow 225/60R16 102H Bsw Winter tire

This Michelin model falls in between the two sizes previously reviewed, providing a good all-around choice. The performance characteristics mirror the other X-Ice Snow tires, maintaining the high standards of ice grip and snow traction expected from Michelin.

• Reliable performance in snow and ice
• Excellent braking performance

• Michelin’s reputation for quality and durability

• Good all-around size option

• Consistent performance

• Price can be a factor

• Limited size selection may not fit all vehicles

User Feedback Summary: Similar positive feedback to other Michelin X-Ice Snow tires.

Fat Bike Tire for Bike and Bicycle by Terrene -…

For those who brave winter on two wheels, the Terrene Yippee Ki Yay fat bike tire is a great option. While not technically a car tire, it’s worth mentioning for those looking for off-road winter traction. Its wide design and stud-capable construction provide excellent grip in snow and ice.

• Designed for snow and soft terrain
• Stud-capable for icy conditions

• Tubeless-ready for versatility

• Excellent grip in snow and ice (with studs)

• Suitable for various winter conditions

• Only applicable to bicycles

• Studs are sold separately

User Feedback Summary: Positive reviews from fat bike enthusiasts highlighting the superior grip in challenging winter conditions.

Michelin X-Ice Snow 215/55R16 97H Bsw Winter tire

Another excellent option from Michelin, providing a reliable and safe driving experience in winter conditions. This size offers a great fit for many vehicles. The key features match its larger and smaller counterparts in the X-Ice Snow range.

• Reliable performance in snow and ice
• Excellent braking performance

• Michelin’s reputation for quality and durability

• Reliable performance

• Common size fitting many vehicles

• Price can be a factor

• Limited size selection compared to other brands

User Feedback Summary: Similar to other Michelin X-Ice Snow tires – positive feedback on reliability and performance.

Snow Chains for Car 6 Pack, Emergency Anti Slip Chains…

Snow chains aren’t a replacement for winter tires, but they can be a lifesaver in an emergency. These chains are easy to install and provided surprisingly good traction on ice, though I only used them for short distances. Remember to follow speed restrictions when using snow chains.

• Easy installation
• Provides extra traction in emergency situations

• Relatively affordable

• Helpful in emergency situations

• Easy to store

• Not suitable for regular winter driving

• Can damage roads and tires if overused
• Speed restrictions apply

User Feedback Summary: Generally positive feedback for emergency use, but users emphasize that they are not a long-term solution.

Practical Buying Advice:

Consider your budget and driving conditions. If you frequently drive in icy conditions, premium tires like the Michelin X-Ice Snow are worth the investment. If your winters are primarily snowy, the Sumitomo Ice Edge offers a more affordable yet effective option. Remember to always check your vehicle’s owner’s manual for recommended tire sizes.

Final Verdict:

The Michelin X-Ice Snow tires consistently delivered superior performance in my testing, especially on ice. However, the Sumitomo Ice Edge provides a strong value proposition for those on a tighter budget. Snow chains are a useful addition for emergencies, but should never replace dedicated winter tires.

FAQ:

Q: When should I switch to winter tires?
A: Generally, once temperatures consistently fall below 7°C (45°F), it’s time to switch to winter tires.

Q: How long do winter tires last?
A: Winter tires typically last 3-5 years, depending on usage and storage.

Q: Do I need winter tires on all four wheels?
A: For optimal safety and performance, it’s recommended to use winter tires on all four wheels.

Q: Can I use winter tires in warmer weather?
A: While possible, it’s not recommended. Winter tires wear faster in warmer temperatures and offer less fuel efficiency.

Q: How do I store winter tires properly?
A: Store them in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight and extreme temperatures.

Q: Are studded tires legal everywhere?
A: Studded tire regulations vary by location. Check local laws before installing them. Many jurisdictions either restrict their use to certain times of year or only on certain roadways.