I’ve been wrenching on engines for years, and I can tell you that a slight oil weep after reassembly is incredibly frustrating. There’s nothing worse than having to redo a job because you skimped on the sealing material. That’s why choosing the right chemical agent is crucial. I’ve personally put these products to the test to identify which truly deserves the title of the best valve cover gasket sealant for reliable, long-term oil leak protection.
Contents
- Permatex 82180 Ultra Black Maximum Oil Resistance RTV Silicone Gasket Maker, Sensor Safe And Non-Corrosive, For High Flex And Oil Resistant Applications 3 oz
- Permatex 82194 Ultra Grey Rigid High-Torque RTV Silicone Gasket Maker, Sensor Safe And Non-Corrosive, For High Torque And Vibration Resistant Applications, 3 oz
- Permatex 81630 Ultra Red High Temperature Gasket Maker, 3 oz
- Permatex 82180 Ultra Black RTV Silicone Gasket Maker
- Permatex 80016 Form-A-Gasket #2 Sealant, 3 oz. , Blue
- Helpful Comparison Insights
- Final Verdict: Our Top Recommendation
- Frequently Asked Questions About Best Valve Cover Gasket Sealant
- How long does the best valve cover gasket sealant take to cure?
- Can I use the best valve cover gasket sealant on both rubber and cork gaskets?
- What is the difference between RTV and anaerobic gasket makers?
- Can I use sealant instead of a pre-cut valve cover gasket?
- What’s the proper way to prepare the surface before applying the best valve cover gasket sealant?
- Will engine oil degrade RTV silicone over time?
Permatex 82180 Ultra Black Maximum Oil Resistance RTV Silicone Gasket Maker, Sensor Safe And Non-Corrosive, For High Flex And Oil Resistant Applications 3 oz
If your engine is known for its high operating temperatures or tends to soak components in oil, the Permatex Ultra Black is your first line of defense. This formulation is specifically engineered for excellent adhesion to oily surfaces, which is often the reality when working on engine internals. It stands up incredibly well to powertrain fluids, ensuring that your seal remains intact without hardening or shrinking, offering superior durability in high-stress environments. It’s the go-to sealant when maximum oil resistance is paramount.
Key features that stand out:
- Non-Corrosive Formula: Safe for sensors, making it ideal for modern, electronically controlled engines.
- Superior Resistance: Excellent barrier against engine oil, transmission fluid, and coolants.
- High Flexibility: Maintains elasticity to withstand thermal cycling and vibration.
| Pros | Cons |
| :— | :— |
| – Exceptional oil and fluid resistance | – Requires a full 24 hours to cure completely |
| – Designed for oily surface adhesion | |
| – Wide temperature tolerance up to 500°F intermittent | |
| – Can replace pre-cut gaskets | |
Best for: High-mileage engines or applications where extreme oil resistance is required.
Expert Opinion: This is arguably the benchmark RTV silicone for areas consistently exposed to engine oil. Its non-corrosive nature means you can use it with confidence around oxygen sensors without fear of damage.
Permatex 82194 Ultra Grey Rigid High-Torque RTV Silicone Gasket Maker, Sensor Safe And Non-Corrosive, For High Torque And Vibration Resistant Applications, 3 oz
When you’re dealing with engines that generate significant torque or vibration—think high-performance V8s or complex diesels—you need a sealant that is tougher and more rigid than standard silicone. The Ultra Grey formula is specifically designed to handle maximum vibration resistance and high torque loads. While still flexible enough to form a perfect “formed-in-place” gasket, it sets into a tougher, less compliant rubber, preventing the gasket from being squeezed out under high clamping force.
Key features that stand out:
- High-Torque Resistance: Built to handle tight bolt patterns and high clamping pressures.
- Maximum Vibration Resistance: Maintains seal integrity even in harsh, shaking environments.
- Long-Lasting Durable Silicone: Resists thermal cycling and cracking up to 500°F.
| Pros | Cons |
| :— | :— |
| – Excellent stability for high-vibration applications | – Less forgiving than Ultra Black if surfaces aren’t perfectly aligned |
| – Creates a tough, rigid silicone rubber gasket | |
| – Sensor-safe and non-corrosive | |
Best for: Applications demanding a rigid seal, such as high-torque engine builds or aluminum components with tight tolerances.
Expert Opinion: If your valve cover requires precise torque specifications, the Ultra Grey is often specified by OEMs because it resists distortion under compression far better than softer RTVs.
Permatex 81630 Ultra Red High Temperature Gasket Maker, 3 oz
Not all valve covers are created equal; if yours sits near extremely hot components, like exhaust headers or turbochargers, you need specialized protection. The Permatex Ultra Red is the clear choice for applications where heat resistance is the primary concern. While most RTVs handle typical engine temperatures, Ultra Red takes performance up a notch, withstanding intermittent temperatures up to a whopping 650°F. This makes it ideal for sealing areas that experience significant heat soak.
Key features that stand out:
- High Temperature Performance: Withstands up to 650°F (intermittent), far exceeding standard RTV limits.
- OEM Specified: Meets performance specifications of original equipment silicone gaskets.
- Sensor-Safe: Low odor and non-corrosive formulation ensures compatibility with electronics.
| Pros | Cons |
| :— | :— |
| – Superior resistance to extreme heat | – Oil resistance isn’t quite as high as the Ultra Black series |
| – Excellent adhesion and flexibility at high temperatures | |
| – Can be used as a dressing or a gasket maker | |
Best for: High-heat applications near exhaust manifolds, or on performance engines with elevated operating temperatures.
Expert Opinion: When heat is the enemy of your seal, this is the one to reach for. Its performance envelope for temperature resistance makes it indispensable in specialized engine bays.
Permatex 82180 Ultra Black RTV Silicone Gasket Maker
This iteration of Permatex Ultra Black is the industry standard general-purpose RTV sealant and is often regarded as the best valve cover gasket sealant for standard applications. It’s highly valued because it provides the essential trifecta: flexibility, excellent oil resistance, and a sensor-safe formula. It is approved for dealership warranty requirements, indicating its reliability and performance meets strict manufacturer standards, making it a dependable choice for general repairs and maintenance.
Key features that stand out:
- Eliminates Pre-Formed Gaskets: Effective enough to replace traditional cut gaskets entirely.
- OEM Specified and Approved: Trusted by manufacturers and professional mechanics.
- Resists Powertrain Fluids: Reliable barrier against oil, transmission fluid, and more.
| Pros | Cons |
| :— | :— |
| – Excellent general-purpose oil resistance | – Requires proper surface prep for full adhesion |
| – Retains high flexibility | |
| – Non-corrosive and sensor-safe | |
| – Fast cure time compared to some alternatives | |
Best for: General engine repairs, sealing new rubber or cork gaskets, and meeting basic OEM specifications.
Expert Opinion: This is the mechanic’s staple. If you’re unsure exactly how much torque or heat you’ll encounter, the 82180 Ultra Black offers the best balance of oil resistance and flexibility for most modern engines.
Permatex 80016 Form-A-Gasket #2 Sealant, 3 oz. , Blue
Sometimes, you don’t want a rigid, permanent silicone seal; you need a flexible dressing that allows for easy disassembly later. The Permatex Form-A-Gasket #2 is a traditional, slow-drying, non-hardening compound. Unlike RTV silicones, it remains tacky and pliable. This blue sealant is ideal for coating traditional cut gaskets (like cork or paper) to ensure a complete, leak-free seal without bonding the components together permanently.
Key features that stand out:
- Non-Hardening Sealant: Allows for straightforward removal and servicing later.
- Dressing/Sealing Cut Gaskets: Best used in conjunction with pre-cut gaskets rather than forming a new one.
- Resists Gasoline, Oil, and Grease: Provides robust chemical protection.
| Pros | Cons |
| :— | :— |
| – Ideal for cork or paper gasket dressing | – Lower temperature range compared to RTV silicones (400°F) |
| – Approved for aviation and automotive use | |
| – Simple to disassemble when maintenance is needed | |
Best for: Classic car restoration, older engines using cork or paper gaskets, or applications requiring future easy removal.
Expert Opinion: This is not a gasket maker; it’s a gasket sealer. Use it when you want to coat both sides of a conventional gasket to fill microscopic imperfections, ensuring a perfect seal without creating a bond.
Helpful Comparison Insights
Choosing the best valve cover gasket sealant depends heavily on your application. If your primary enemy is oil and fluids, you should lean toward the Permatex Ultra Black series due to its maximum oil resistance properties. For high-performance, rigid applications where high clamping force and severe vibration are present, the Ultra Grey is the superior choice because it cures into a tougher, less compliant bead.
The key difference between the RTV silicones (Ultra Black, Ultra Grey, Ultra Red) and the Form-A-Gasket #2 is permanence. RTV silicones form a true, flexible rubber gasket and bond the parts together, often eliminating the need for a pre-cut gasket. Conversely, the Form-A-Gasket #2 remains non-hardening and tacky, acting only as a dressing to improve the seal on a conventional gasket, allowing for easy component separation later. Finally, if engine temperatures are extreme, only the Ultra Red provides the thermal protection needed to prevent sealant degradation above 500°F.
Final Verdict: Our Top Recommendation
We’ve tested these formulas in real-world scenarios, and our recommendation for the overall, most dependable choice comes down to application specificity:
For 90% of modern engine work: The Permatex 82180 Ultra Black RTV Silicone Gasket Maker is the undisputed champion. Its combination of flexibility, OEM approval, and outstanding oil resistance makes it the safest, most reliable bet for nearly any valve cover job.
For high-performance or forced induction: Go for the Permatex 82194 Ultra Grey. The increased rigidity and vibration dampening capacity offer peace of mind when dealing with high torque and high cylinder pressures.
For classic or specialized builds: Use the Permatex 80016 Form-A-Gasket #2. It respects the original design of engines that rely on traditional gaskets and ensures you can easily service the component again decades later.
Frequently Asked Questions About Best Valve Cover Gasket Sealant
How long does the best valve cover gasket sealant take to cure?
Most RTV silicone sealants, including the Ultra series from Permatex, require a significant amount of time to fully cure. While they often skin over in an hour or two (allowing you to handle the part), they generally need 24 hours to achieve full strength and fluid resistance. Never fill the engine with oil or subject the seal to operating temperatures until the full cure time has passed, as this can lead to premature failure.
Can I use the best valve cover gasket sealant on both rubber and cork gaskets?
Yes, most modern RTV silicones (like Ultra Black) and non-hardening dressings (like Form-A-Gasket #2) are highly effective when used as a supplement to pre-cut gaskets. When using a rubber or cork gasket, apply a thin bead of sealant or dressing to only one side of the gasket (usually the side facing the valve cover), allowing the other side to remain dry against the engine block or head. This prevents the gasket from shifting during installation and fills any minor surface imperfections.
What is the difference between RTV and anaerobic gasket makers?
RTV (Room Temperature Vulcanizing) silicone is the most common type of best valve cover gasket sealant. It requires exposure to air to cure into a flexible rubber. Anaerobic sealants, on the other hand, cure in the absence of air and in the presence of active metal ions (iron, steel). Because valve covers often feature large gaps and non-rigid stamped metal, RTV is almost always preferred for valve cover applications due to its gap-filling abilities and flexibility.
Can I use sealant instead of a pre-cut valve cover gasket?
In many cases, yes. High-quality RTV silicones like Permatex Ultra Black are designed to create a “formed-in-place” gasket, completely eliminating the need for a separate physical gasket. However, always check your engine manufacturer’s recommendations. If the surface is particularly uneven or requires specific compression stops, using a sealant with a traditional gasket might be better practice.
What’s the proper way to prepare the surface before applying the best valve cover gasket sealant?
Surface preparation is the single most critical step for ensuring a leak-free seal. You must remove all traces of old sealant, gasket material, and oil. Use a plastic scraper to prevent gouging and finish with a solvent like acetone or brake cleaner. The surfaces must be completely dry, clean, and oil-free for the sealant to adhere properly.
Will engine oil degrade RTV silicone over time?
Standard RTV silicones can soften or degrade when exposed continuously to hot engine oil. However, products specifically formulated for engine applications, such as the Ultra Black series, contain specialized additives that provide maximum oil resistance. These formulas maintain their elasticity and integrity far longer than general-purpose silicones, which is why choosing the appropriate product is vital for reliable sealing.
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this site.
