Finding the right fuel pump for your Jeep Comanche can feel like navigating a minefield. This guide will help you choose the best option for your needs and budget by reviewing seven popular fuel pump choices, comparing their features, and highlighting user feedback. We’ll cover compatibility, performance, and installation ease, so you can confidently tackle this important repair or upgrade.
| IMAGE | PRODUCT NAME | AMAZON LINK |
|---|---|---|
|
GELUOXI Electric Fuel Pump Gas Tank Sending Unit… |
View on Amazon |
|
ANTUKO Fuel Tank Sending Unit with the Fuel Pump… |
View on Amazon |
|
Electric Fuel Pump Assembly FIT 2015–2019 Sonata, 2016–2020… |
View on Amazon |
|
Electric Fuel Pump Assembly Compatible with 1988 1989 1990… |
View on Amazon |
|
dawfall 1 PC Car Fuel Pump, Vehicle Piston Fuel Supply… |
View on Amazon |
|
DACIRTY Fuel Pump Kit – 12V Low Pressure 3-6 PSI… |
View on Amazon |
|
TRQ Fuel Pump Module Assembly Compatible with 1997-1999… |
View on Amazon |
GELUOXI Electric Fuel Pump Gas Tank Sending Unit…
This fuel pump specifically targets 1987-1990 Jeep Comanche MJ 4.0L models with 18 and 23.5-gallon tanks. It’s a direct replacement designed to restore your vehicle’s fuel delivery to factory specifications.
- Fits 1987-1990 Jeep Comanche MJ 4.0L (18 & 23.5-gallon tanks)
- Part# JPSU-6P4.0
- OHM Range: Full 80-90, Empty 0-5
- Pressure 90-110 PSI
- Flow Rate 45 GPH
Pros:
– Direct replacement for specific Comanche models
– Meets factory specifications
Cons:
– Limited compatibility – only for certain Comanche years and engines.
User Feedback Summary: Generally positive reviews from users who found it a reliable replacement for their aging fuel pumps.
ANTUKO Fuel Tank Sending Unit with the Fuel Pump…
The ANTUKO unit is another option for older Comanches, aiming to be a direct replacement for several part numbers. Its focus is on providing a long service life through its manufacturing process.
- Replacement for 1987-1990 Comanche
- Part Numbers: JPSU-6, JPSU-6P4.0
- Claims improved longevity through manufacturing processes
Pros:
– Designed for long service life
– Aims for direct replacement fitment
Cons:
– Vague on specific compatibility; double-check your vehicle’s specific requirements before purchase.
– Lack of specific performance data (PSI, GPH).
User Feedback Summary: User reviews are mixed; some report success, others mention compatibility issues. Careful checking of vehicle specifications is crucial.
Electric Fuel Pump Assembly FIT 2015–2019 Sonata, 2016–2020…
This fuel pump is NOT for Comanches. It’s included here to highlight the importance of checking compatibility. This pump fits various Hyundai and Kia models and shows how crucial it is to verify the correct part number and vehicle fitment before ordering. This should serve as a cautionary tale to avoid mismatched purchases.
Pros:
– None (inapplicable to Comanches)
Cons:
– Completely incompatible with Comanche vehicles.
User Feedback Summary: Reviews are relevant only to Hyundai and Kia vehicles.
(for reference, to show incompatibility)
Electric Fuel Pump Assembly Compatible with 1988 1989 1990…
This pump boasts compatibility with a wider range of vehicles, including some Chevy and GMC trucks from the late 80s and early 90s. While not specifically designed for Comanches, its broad compatibility makes it worth considering if you can verify the correct fitment for your specific Comanche year and engine.
- Wide compatibility with various Chevy and GMC trucks
- Replaces several OEM part numbers (check for Comanche compatibility)
- Easy installation claimed
Pros:
– Potentially wide compatibility (verify your Comanche’s fitment)
– Claims easy installation
Cons:
– Requires careful checking of compatibility with your specific Comanche model.
– Broad compatibility might indicate less precise fitment for specific vehicles.
User Feedback Summary: Reviews are mixed, highlighting the importance of ensuring compatibility with the specific Comanche model before purchase.
dawfall 1 PC Car Fuel Pump, Vehicle Piston Fuel Supply…
This is a more general-purpose fuel pump marketed as universal. It emphasizes its plunger design for strong suction and high-quality materials. However, its universal nature might mean less precise fitment for a specific Comanche model compared to a dedicated Comanche fuel pump.
- Plunger-type fuel supply
- High-quality metal construction
- Claimed high suction power
Pros:
– Relatively inexpensive
– Strong suction (claimed)
Cons:
– Universal fit, may require modifications for optimal performance on a Comanche.
– May not match the OEM specifications perfectly.
User Feedback Summary: User feedback is limited and varies widely. Use with caution and confirm fitment.
DACIRTY Fuel Pump Kit – 12V Low Pressure 3-6 PSI…
Similar to the dawfall pump, this is another universal low-pressure fuel pump. It’s best suited for applications requiring low pressure, and its suitability for a Comanche depends greatly on the specific requirements of the vehicle. Double check pressure ratings before purchase.
- Plunger-type pump
- Low pressure (3-6 PSI)
- 12V operation
Pros:
– Inexpensive
– Easy to install (claimed)
Cons:
– Low pressure – may not be suitable for all Comanche applications.
– Universal fit – may not be a direct replacement.
User Feedback Summary: User reviews are scant and lack detail regarding Comanche usage.
TRQ Fuel Pump Module Assembly Compatible with 1997-1999…
This fuel pump module is for a different model year range; It’s not compatible with the 1987-1990 Comanches focused on in this article. It is included to again highlight the importance of checking year and model compatibility.
Pros:
– None (inapplicable to 1987-1990 Comanches)
Cons:
– Incompletely incompatible with the target Comanche model years.
User Feedback Summary: Reviews are relevant only to compatible vehicles.
(for reference, to show incompatibility)
Practical Buying Advice:
Before buying, always:
- Verify your Comanche’s year, engine size, and fuel tank capacity. This is crucial for ensuring compatibility.
- Check the OEM part numbers for your fuel pump. Many aftermarket pumps list the OEM numbers they replace.
- Compare flow rate (GPH) and pressure (PSI) specifications to your original pump or your Comanche’s specifications.
- Read user reviews carefully to gauge real-world performance and potential issues.
- Consider your budget and the level of DIY experience you have before making your purchase.
FAQ:
Q: How often do Comanche fuel pumps typically need replacing?
A: This depends on various factors, including driving habits, fuel quality, and overall vehicle maintenance. However, a fuel pump’s lifespan is generally between 100,000 and 150,000 miles, though it can fail earlier due to wear and tear or other issues.
Q: What are the signs of a failing fuel pump?
A: Symptoms include difficulty starting, sputtering, loss of power, reduced fuel economy, and a whining noise from the fuel tank area.
Q: Is it difficult to replace a fuel pump in a Comanche?
A: The difficulty varies depending on your mechanical skills and the specific year of your Comanche. For some, it’s a straightforward job, while others may find it more challenging. Always consult a repair manual or video tutorial.
Q: Can I use any fuel pump for my Comanche?
A: No, you absolutely must use a fuel pump that’s compatible with your specific Comanche model year and engine. Using an incompatible pump can damage your fuel system.
Q: What tools will I need to replace a fuel pump?
A: You’ll likely need basic hand tools (sockets, wrenches), a fuel pump removal tool, and possibly a fuel pressure gauge. Refer to your repair manual for specific tools required for your Comanche’s model year.
Q: What should I do if the replacement pump doesn’t work correctly?
A: If the new pump doesn’t resolve the fuel delivery problem, other issues in your fuel system may be at play. Seek professional help from a mechanic to diagnose and repair the problem.
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this site.
